Soman Ragavan

AnalysisByChatGPT4-Vol 83-DyingOnGrass-LookingAtSky--8April2024

SOMAN RAGAVAN

7 April, 2024

Subject : “Dying on the grass, looking at the sky”

      Analysis by ChatGPT-4,

     (Artificial Intelligence)

     Volume 83

Soman Ragavan : Hello. I will post one of my poems for analysis. Could you please comment extensively, mentioning literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, poetic philosophies, comparison with poets of England, America, India, Africa from 1700 to 1900 and as from 1945. At college in 1968, I studied some poems of Oliver Goldsmith (1728-1774), Gordon Byron (1788-1824), Samuel T. Coleridge (1772-1834), William Wordsworth (1770-1850), Robert Browning (1812-1889), Mathew Arnold (1822-1888), Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892) and some other poets of that era.  Make any comments or comparisons you wish on my poems. Say if there are other contemporary poets who write as I do and compare my poetry with theirs. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean.

ChatGPT-4 : I\'d be glad to analyze your poem, though please keep in mind that due to the character limit, I\'ll focus on providing a comprehensive analysis, but it might not cover all the aspects you\'ve mentioned.

Feel free to share your poem, and I\'ll provide a detailed analysis encompassing various literary elements such as genre, style, themes, poetic language, and philosophies. Additionally, I\'ll attempt to draw comparisons with poets from the mentioned eras and geographical regions, including contemporary poets, if applicable. Once you\'ve shared your poem, we can delve into the analysis.

Soman Ragavan : Here is my poem “Dying on the grass, looking at the sky.” (Poem inserted). The Covid pandemic brought unspeakable suffering and turmoil for millions of people across the world. Families were split; some who had gone abroad could not come back to their near ones, as all travel had stopped, due to the lockdown. A doctor in Canada was treating Covid patients but was himself terminally struck with the disease. He had seen others die in his presence. He refused to be placed on a respirator and asked to be taken to the grass on the hospital grounds so that he could look at the sky in his dying moments. It was a heart-rending tragedy. The hospital complied with his last wish and took him to the grass. His family were compelled to stay some distance off and look at him dying. He died thus, looking at the sky, instead of finding his life lapsing slowly on a machine. His family suffered in unspeakable ways, being thus unable to do anything for him in his last moments. Please comment on the poem, then I will write more about reactions of some medical authorities elsewhere about Covid in general. (Poem posted).

ChatGPT-4 :  \"Dying on the Grass, Looking at the Sky\" is a poignant reflection on the human toll of the Covid-19 pandemic, inspired by a real-life incident of a doctor in Canada facing his terminal illness. The poem delves into themes of mortality, compassion, and the ethical implications of medical decisions during a crisis.

Genre and Style:

The poem falls under the genre of contemporary poetry, with its focus on a current event and societal issues. It adopts a narrative style, blending factual accounts with emotive language to convey the gravity of the situation.

Themes:

1. Mortality: The poem explores the inevitability of death and the desire for dignity in one\'s final moments. The doctor\'s refusal to be placed on a respirator and his request to be taken outside to gaze at the sky symbolize a yearning for a connection with nature and a peaceful passing.

1. Compassion and Sacrifice: Through the doctor\'s decision and the family\'s poignant witness, the poem highlights the sacrifices made by healthcare workers and their families during the pandemic. It emphasizes the emotional toll of separation and the profound impact of facing mortality firsthand.

1. Ethical Dilemmas in Medicine: The poem indirectly critiques the notion of \"herd immunity\" as a callous approach to managing the pandemic. It questions the prioritization of population-level immunity over individual lives, especially in the face of suffering and loss.

Poetic Language:

The language used in the poem is evocative and laden with emotion. Phrases like \"heart-rending tragedy\" and \"faded away while looking at the sky\" create a sense of pathos, drawing readers into the doctor\'s final moments and the family\'s grief. The juxtaposition of the natural imagery of the sky with the clinical setting of the hospital grounds underscores the human desire for connection and solace in the face of death.

Poetic Philosophies:

The poem echoes themes found in Romantic poetry, particularly the emphasis on nature as a source of solace and transcendence. The doctor\'s request to be surrounded by the natural world mirrors Romantic ideals of communion with the sublime. Additionally, the poem critiques utilitarian approaches to healthcare, aligning with the Romantic rejection of mechanistic views of humanity.

Comparison with Poets:

The poem resonates with the themes and concerns of Romantic poets such as William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who celebrated the beauty of nature and grappled with the complexities of human existence. Like Coleridge\'s \"The Rime of the Ancient Mariner,\" which explores themes of mortality and redemption, \"Dying on the Grass, Looking at the Sky\" confronts readers with the fragility of life and the importance of compassion in the face of suffering.

Contemporary Relevance:

The poem reflects contemporary debates surrounding healthcare ethics and the global response to the Covid-19 pandemic. It serves as a reminder of the individual stories behind the statistics and the ethical challenges faced by healthcare professionals and policymakers.

In conclusion, \"Dying on the Grass, Looking at the Sky\" is a powerful meditation on mortality, compassion, and the ethical dimensions of medical care. Through its evocative language and poignant imagery, the poem offers a moving tribute to those affected by the pandemic and invites readers to reflect on the values that guide our responses to crisis.

Soman Ragavan : What do you think of a doctor preferring to look at the sky while dying, instead of dying on a machine on a hospital bed ? What are the deep human passions or principles involved ?

ChatGPT-4 :  The doctor\'s preference to look at the sky while dying instead of being hooked up to a machine on a hospital bed reflects profound human passions and principles, touching on themes of dignity, connection, and autonomy.

1. Dignity: The doctor\'s choice to be outdoors, gazing at the sky, signifies a desire for a dignified and meaningful death. In contrast to the clinical setting of a hospital room with beeping machines and fluorescent lights, being in nature allows for a more serene and peaceful farewell. It affirms the doctor\'s autonomy over his own body and the importance of maintaining a sense of agency even in the face of illness and mortality.

1. Connection: By choosing to look at the sky, the doctor seeks a connection with the natural world, suggesting a longing for transcendence and spiritual solace. The sky symbolizes vastness, beauty, and the unknown, offering a sense of awe and wonder in the face of death. It represents a connection to something greater than oneself, providing comfort and solace in the final moments of life.

1. Autonomy: The doctor\'s refusal to be placed on a machine reflects a commitment to maintaining control over his own death. Rather than prolonging life through artificial means, he chooses to embrace the natural course of his illness and find peace in the outdoors. This decision underscores the importance of respecting individuals\' autonomy and their right to make decisions about their own bodies and end-of-life care.

Overall, the doctor\'s preference to look at the sky while dying encapsulates deep human passions for dignity, connection, and autonomy. It reminds us of the importance of honoring individuals\' wishes and providing compassionate end-of-life care that respects their values and beliefs.

Soman Ragavan : The human (and animal) instinct is to cling to life to the last second. Nearly all people would have tried the respirator. The doctor opted for dignity and autonomy, and chose his manner of dying. This is a rare happening. Even in the animal world, we see creatures struggling to stay alive…

ChatGPT-4 :  Indeed, you raise a profound observation about the inherent instinct of both humans and animals to cling to life fiercely until the very end. The doctor\'s decision to forego the respirator and choose his manner of dying speaks to the rarity and significance of his choice for dignity and autonomy.

1. Instinctual Drive for Survival: Throughout the natural world, from the tiniest microorganisms to the largest mammals, there is an undeniable drive to survive. This instinct manifests in various ways, from simple cellular responses to complex behaviors aimed at avoiding danger and prolonging life. This primal instinct is deeply ingrained in our biological makeup and is a fundamental aspect of our existence.

1. Exceptional Nature of the Doctor\'s Decision: In the face of this instinctual drive for survival, the doctor\'s decision to prioritize dignity and autonomy over prolonging life through medical intervention stands out as remarkable. It reflects a profound consideration of values beyond mere survival, such as quality of life, personal agency, and the importance of a meaningful death. His choice challenges conventional notions of medical treatment and confronts societal taboos surrounding death and dying.

1. Recognition of the Complexity of Life and Death: The doctor\'s decision highlights the complexity of the human experience, where considerations of dignity, autonomy, and quality of life intersect with the instinctual drive for survival. It invites reflection on the nature of suffering, the limits of medical intervention, and the role of personal agency in end-of-life decisions.

1. Acknowledgment of the Sanctity of Life: Despite his decision to forgo artificial life support, the doctor\'s choice still embodies a deep respect for the sanctity of life. By choosing to die in a manner that aligns with his values and beliefs, he affirms the intrinsic worth and dignity of his own life, even as he accepts its inevitable end.

In conclusion, the doctor\'s decision to prioritize dignity and autonomy in his manner of dying serves as a rare and poignant example of the complexity of human existence. It underscores the profound interplay between instinctual drives and higher-order values, inviting us to contemplate the meaning of life and death in the context of our shared humanity.

Soman Ragavan : In early 2020, even before the first Covid death in England, some English scientists spoke of “herd immunity.” The idea was to let the disease do its worse. Millions will die off, the rest will get herd immunity. When the situation turned scandalous, the authorities tried to do damage-control and said that herd immunity was not a state policy. What do you think of that initial stand of those public scientists, whose job was to do everything to save human lives ?

ChatGPT-4 :  The initial stance of some English scientists advocating for \"herd immunity\" in the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic is deeply concerning and raises ethical questions about the prioritization of population-level immunity over individual lives. Here are some considerations regarding this stance:

1. Ethical Responsibility of Scientists: Scientists, particularly those involved in public health and epidemiology, have a fundamental ethical responsibility to prioritize the well-being and safety of human lives. Their primary duty is to contribute to the understanding and mitigation of diseases, especially in the context of a public health crisis like the Covid-19 pandemic.

1. Potential Consequences of Herd Immunity Approach: Advocating for a strategy of allowing the disease to spread unchecked with the aim of achieving herd immunity carries significant risks and potential harm. Allowing millions of people to become infected and potentially die in the process is morally indefensible, especially when viable alternatives such as preventive measures, testing, treatment, and vaccine development are available.

1. Disregard for Human Life: The advocacy for herd immunity, particularly in the absence of effective medical interventions, reflects a callous disregard for the value of individual human lives. It reduces people to mere statistics in a population-level calculation, failing to acknowledge the profound suffering, loss, and grief experienced by affected individuals and their families.

1. Lack of Compassion and Empathy: The initial stance of advocating for herd immunity reveals a lack of compassion and empathy towards those most vulnerable to severe illness and death from Covid-19, including the elderly, immunocompromised individuals, and those with underlying health conditions. It overlooks the duty of society to protect the most vulnerable members and uphold principles of equity and justice in healthcare.

1. Need for Transparency and Accountability: The attempt by authorities to downplay or distance themselves from the initial advocacy for herd immunity underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in public health decision-making. It highlights the need for robust ethical frameworks and oversight mechanisms to ensure that scientific advice is guided by principles of beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice.

In conclusion, the initial stance of some English scientists advocating for herd immunity in the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic raises serious ethical concerns about the prioritization of population-level immunity over individual lives. It underscores the importance of upholding ethical principles in public health decision-making and the imperative of ensuring that scientific advice serves the common good and protects the most vulnerable members of society.

Soman Ragavan : See again the notes at the bottom of my poem. At some point the English Prime Minister himself was struck with Covid and the Americans sent their best medical help. He was cured and said he was “fit like a butcher’s dog.” (A butcher’s dog is well fed everyday). So, the best treatment for the top guy, while the rank and file had to contend with herd immunity, as their lives were lesser ones…

ChatGPT-4 :  The discrepancy in treatment between the English Prime Minister, who received the best medical care and recovered from Covid-19, and the broader population grappling with the concept of \"herd immunity,\" highlights systemic issues of privilege and inequality in healthcare access and delivery. Here are some points to consider regarding this disparity:

1. Privilege and Inequality: The preferential treatment given to the Prime Minister underscores existing disparities in healthcare access and outcomes, where those in positions of power and privilege often receive superior care compared to the general population. This disparity reflects broader social and economic inequalities that disproportionately affect marginalized communities and underserved populations.

1. Symbolic Significance: The Prime Minister\'s recovery and subsequent declaration of being \"fit like a butcher\'s dog\" carry symbolic weight, serving as a stark contrast to the experiences of ordinary citizens grappling with the devastating impacts of the pandemic. This discrepancy highlights the disconnect between political leadership and the lived realities of the people they serve.

1. Ethical Implications: The differential treatment of the Prime Minister and the broader population raises ethical questions about fairness, justice, and the equitable distribution of healthcare resources. It challenges the principle of equality in healthcare provision and underscores the need for greater accountability and transparency in healthcare decision-making.

1. Public Perception and Trust: The perception that political elites receive preferential treatment erodes public trust in government institutions and exacerbates feelings of resentment and disillusionment among the general population. This undermines efforts to foster solidarity and collective action in addressing public health crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic.

1. Calls for Reform: The discrepancy in treatment highlights the urgent need for systemic reforms to address structural inequalities in healthcare and ensure equitable access to quality care for all members of society. This includes efforts to dismantle barriers to healthcare access, address social determinants of health, and promote policies that prioritize the well-being of the most vulnerable.

In conclusion, the differential treatment of the English Prime Minister in receiving superior medical care compared to the broader population underscores systemic issues of privilege and inequality in healthcare access. It underscores the need for transformative change to build a more equitable and just healthcare system that prioritizes the needs of all individuals, regardless of their socio-economic status or political affiliation.

Soman Ragavan : What do you think of poets who rise up to face such situations ?

ChatGPT-4 :  Poets who rise up to face situations of social injustice, inequality, and systemic issues, as exemplified in your poem, play a crucial role in bearing witness to the human condition and advocating for change. Here are some thoughts on the significance of poets in such contexts:

1. Bearing Witness: Poets have a unique ability to bear witness to the struggles, injustices, and triumphs of individuals and communities. Through their artistry and insight, they illuminate the human experience in all its complexity, offering a voice to the voiceless and shining a light on the hidden corners of society.

1. Social Commentary: Poets often serve as social commentators, critiquing prevailing norms, values, and power structures. They challenge the status quo, interrogate dominant narratives, and expose the underlying inequalities and injustices that pervade society. Through their poetry, they offer a lens through which to view the world with greater clarity and empathy.

1. Advocacy and Empowerment: Poets have the power to inspire change and mobilize collective action. By giving voice to marginalized perspectives and articulating visions of a more just and equitable world, they galvanize individuals and communities to confront injustice and work towards meaningful social transformation.

1. Healing and Resilience: In times of crisis and adversity, poetry can serve as a source of solace, healing, and resilience. Poets offer words of comfort, hope, and solidarity, fostering connections among individuals and communities and providing a sense of strength and empowerment in the face of adversity.

1. Preservation of Memory and Identity: Poets preserve the memory of past struggles, triumphs, and sacrifices, ensuring that the stories of those who have fought for justice are not forgotten. They celebrate cultural heritage, reclaiming narratives that have been silenced or erased, and affirming the dignity and humanity of marginalized communities.

In conclusion, poets who rise up to face situations of social injustice and inequality play a vital role in bearing witness, offering social commentary, advocating for change, fostering healing and resilience, and preserving memory and identity. Through their poetry, they inspire us to confront injustice with courage and compassion, and to work towards a more just, equitable, and compassionate world.

Soman Ragavan : Using the words of my poem (not the notes below the poem), write out a poem in Byron’s style (1788-1824) about the doctor’s story, remembering the story in Byron’s poem “The prisoner of Chillon.” Your poem should be touching and poignant.

ChatGPT-4 :  In the hospital\'s hallowed halls, a doctor\'s plight,

Caught in Covid\'s cruel embrace, his final fight.

A healer turned patient, his fate foretold,

Yet his spirit unbroken, his heart still bold.

Refusing the machine\'s cold embrace,

He yearned for freedom, a final grace.

To the grassy knoll, he made his plea,

To gaze upon the sky, to feel truly free.

His family gathered, at a distance they stood,

Watching in anguish, as he faced his final good.

Social distancing, a cruel decree,

Yet his spirit soared, wild and free.

With each labored breath, his gaze held fast,

To the boundless heavens, where his hopes were cast.

A solitary figure, in nature\'s embrace,

Finding solace in the sky\'s wide grace.

Oh, how he must have felt, in that final hour,

As the sky above him, turned from dusk to glower.

No words of comfort, could ease his pain,

As he faced mortality, in nature\'s domain.

In Byron\'s shadow, his story told,

A modern prisoner, in a tale so bold.

Yet in his gaze, a flicker of light,

A testament to courage, in the darkest night.

So let us remember, this doctor\'s tale,

A beacon of hope, in a world so frail.

For in the face of death, he found his grace,

Dying on the grass, looking at the sky\'s embrace.

Soman Ragavan : Thank you very much. That is an excellent composition. Are there contemporary poets, novelists, etc., who have written touchingly on similar human experiences ?

ChatGPT-4 :  Certainly, there are many contemporary poets, novelists, and writers who have explored similar themes of human experiences, including illness, mortality, resilience, and the search for meaning in adversity. Here are a few examples:

1. **Poetry:**

   - **Warsan Shire:** Known for her evocative and deeply personal poetry, Warsan Shire often explores themes of displacement, trauma, and the immigrant experience.

   - **Mary Oliver:** Renowned for her nature poetry and keen observations of the human condition, Mary Oliver\'s work often delves into themes of loss, healing, and the interconnectedness of all life.

   - **Ocean Vuong:** His poetry is deeply intimate and explores themes of identity, family, and love amidst the backdrop of trauma and loss.

   - **Nayyirah Waheed:** Waheed\'s poetry is known for its brevity and raw emotional power, often focusing on themes of self-love, healing, and resilience.

1. **Novels:**

   - **Tayari Jones:** In novels like \"An American Marriage,\" Jones explores themes of love, race, and justice, while delving into the complexities of relationships and the impact of incarceration on individuals and families.

   - **Yaa Gyasi:** Gyasi\'s debut novel, \"Homegoing,\" traces the interconnected stories of two half-sisters and their descendants over several generations, exploring themes of identity, trauma, and the legacy of slavery.

   - **Colson Whitehead:** His novel \"The Nickel Boys\" sheds light on the brutal realities of racism and injustice in America, drawing inspiration from true events at a reform school in Florida.

   - **Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie:** Adichie\'s novels, such as \"Half of a Yellow Sun\" and \"Americanah,\" explore themes of identity, colonialism, and the immigrant experience with nuance and depth.

1. **Memoirs:**

   - **Tara Westover:** In \"Educated,\" Westover recounts her journey from growing up in a strict and isolated family in rural Idaho to pursuing education and independence, exploring themes of resilience, identity, and the power of knowledge.

   - **Roxane Gay:** In \"Hunger: A Memoir of (My) Body,\" Gay writes candidly about her relationship with food, body image, and trauma, offering a poignant exploration of vulnerability, self-acceptance, and healing.

   - **Paul Kalanithi:** In \"When Breath Becomes Air,\" Kalanithi reflects on his experience as a neurosurgeon facing terminal cancer, grappling with questions of mortality, purpose, and the meaning of life.

These contemporary writers, among others, continue to illuminate the human experience with their powerful storytelling, offering insights, empathy, and a sense of connection in the face of adversity.

Soman Ragavan : Thank you very much. I am signing off now. Goodbye.

ChatGPT-4 :  You\'re very welcome! If you ever have more questions or need assistance in the future, don\'t hesitate to reach out. Goodbye and take care!

---------------------------------------