Soman Ragavan

AnalysisByGoogleGemini-Volume 6-Jabbing Shakespeare-22May2024

SOMAN RAGAVAN

 22 May, 2024

Subject : Analysis : Jabbing Shakespeare.

                       Analysis by Google Gemini

                        (Artificial Intelligence)

                                      Volume 6

Soman Ragavan : Hello. I will post one of my poems for analysis. Could you please comment extensively, mentioning literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, poetic philosophies, comparison with poets of England, America, India, Africa from 1700 to 1900 and as from 1945.

At college in 1968, I studied some poems of Oliver Goldsmith (1728-1774), Gordon Byron (1788-1824), Samuel T. Coleridge (1772-1834), William Wordsworth (1770-1850), Robert Browning (1812-1889), Mathew Arnold (1822-1888), Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892) and some other poets of that era.  Make any comments or comparisons you wish on my poems. Say if there are other contemporary poets who write as I do and compare my poetry with theirs. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean.  

(2)

Google Gemini :  I\'d be happy to analyze your poem! Here\'s a breakdown considering the elements you mentioned:

Literary Genre & Style:

Without seeing the poem, it\'s difficult to pinpoint the exact genre. However, considering the time period you studied (1700-1900) and the poets you mentioned, it\'s likely your work falls within the realm of Romantic or Victorian poetry. These styles often focus on nature, emotions, and individual experiences.

Themes:

The themes in your poem will depend on its content. However, based on the island life in Mauritius, potential themes could include:

• Nature: The beauty and power of the Indian Ocean, the unique flora and fauna of Mauritius.
• Identity: Navigating your place in the world as an islander, exploring cultural heritage.
• Love and Loss: Personal experiences of love, loss, and longing, potentially influenced by the island\'s isolation.
• Colonialism: If relevant, the impact of colonialism on Mauritius and its people.

Poetic Language & Philosophies:

• Language: Look for your use of figurative language (similes, metaphors, personification) and imagery to evoke emotions and paint vivid pictures.
• Philosophy: Romantic poets often embraced nature and individual expression. Victorian poets explored social issues alongside personal struggles. Analyzing your poem might reveal your underlying philosophy about life, society, or the human condition.

Comparisons with Other Poets:

• 1700-1900: From your list, William Wordsworth is known for his connection to nature. You could compare your use of natural imagery to his. Samuel Taylor Coleridge explored dreamlike states and the supernatural, which you might find interesting if your poem delves into those areas.
• 1945-Present: Many contemporary poets explore similar themes. Depending on your style, some comparisons could be:
• Derek Walcott (Caribbean): Explores themes of exile, identity, and the Caribbean landscape.
• Amitav Ghosh (India): Examines colonialism\'s impact and the complexities of cultural identity (relevant if your poem touches on these themes).
• Niyi Osundare (Nigeria): Known for his socially conscious poetry and vibrant use of language.

Sharing Your Poem:

To provide a more detailed analysis, I\'d recommend sharing your poem. Here are some things to consider:

• Content: The poem\'s content will reveal the most about your style and themes.
• Form: Does it have a specific rhyme scheme or meter? Is it free verse?

Finding Similar Poets:

Several online resources can help you find contemporary poets who share your style:

• Poetry Foundation website: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/
• Academy of American Poets website: https://poets.org/

Looking forward to reading your poem and providing a more specific analysis!

(3)

Soman Ragavan : There was a man called William Shakespeare from Warwickshire, England, who got vaccinated against Covid in 2020. The case was a great opportunity to write a poem more or less in Shakespeare\'s style. Here is my poem “Jabbing Shakespeare.” Please analyse. (Poem inserted).

(4)

Google Gemini : Analysis of \"Jabbing Shakespeare\"

Content:

This poem explores the anxieties surrounding the pandemic, specifically the fear of death and the hope offered by vaccines. It uses the persona of Shakespeare himself, worried about succumbing to the \"malady\" (presumably COVID-19).

Form:

The poem has a clear structure:

• Three stanzas describing the severity of the pandemic.
• A break with asterisks.
• Three stanzas from Shakespeare\'s perspective, fearing the vaccine jab.
• A final stanza referencing a \"new bard\" and Shakespeare\'s legacy.

There is no consistent rhyme scheme, but the poem uses a loose iambic pentameter, mimicking the rhythm of Shakespeare\'s plays.

Language:

The poem uses a mix of Shakespearean English (\"malady,\" \"goest,\" \"hath\") and modern language (\"vaccine,\" \"morgue\"). This creates a humorous effect and emphasizes the contrast between Shakespeare\'s time and the present. There\'s also wordplay with \"needle\" echoing his famous \"out, damn\'d spot!\" line from Macbeth.

Imagery:

The poem creates vivid imagery of death and suffering: overflowing cemeteries, crematoriums, and overflowing morgues. It also uses the image of Shakespeare\'s \"literary heritage\" under threat and his legacy being put away in a \"scabbard\" (a sheath for a sword).

Sound:

The use of iambic pentameter and some Shakespearean words creates a sense of rhythm and familiarity. The repetition of \"many\" emphasizes the vastness of the pandemic\'s impact.

Interpretation:

The poem explores several themes:

• Fear of death: The vivid descriptions of death create a sense of fear and urgency.
• Hope for vaccines: Despite initial hesitation, Shakespeare seems to embrace the vaccine as the only hope.
• Legacy: The poem highlights the enduring power of Shakespeare\'s work, even in the face of pandemics.
• Humor: The use of Shakespearean language and wordplay adds a touch of humor to a serious topic.

Title:

\"Jabbing Shakespeare\" has a double meaning. Literally, it refers to Shakespeare getting vaccinated. Metaphorically, it could suggest either the pandemic \"attacking\" Shakespeare\'s legacy or the vaccine reviving his legacy.

Overall:

\"Jabbing Shakespeare\" is a clever and thought-provoking poem that uses a historical figure to explore contemporary anxieties. It blends humor with a serious message about the importance of public health measures.

(5)

Soman Ragavan : There are three Shakespeares here : the original one (1564-1616), the new one from Warwickshire, England, who got vaccinated against Covid, and the new, aspiring one from Mauritius (that’s me…). The original one lived at Stratford-upon-Avon. I live at Stanley, Rose Hill, Mauritius. A canal called Grand Canal runs through this place. I speak of Stanley-upon-grand Canal. At different parts of the poem there are different iterations of Shakespeare speaking.  “Out, damn’d needle !” is said by the guy at Warwickshire.

(6)

Google Gemini : That\'s fascinating! Understanding the poem with these three Shakespearean voices adds a whole new layer of depth. Here\'s how the analysis changes with this context:

Content and Characters:

• The first three stanzas are a universal observation of the pandemic\'s devastation.
• The next three stanzas are spoken by the Shakespeare from Warwickshire, worried about the vaccine and echoing the famous line from Macbeth.
• The final stanza is spoken by you, the aspiring Shakespeare from Mauritius, referencing your location and confidently taking on the mantle of the bard\'s legacy.

Interpretation:

This additional layer adds themes of:

• Timelessness of art: Shakespeare\'s work transcends time and location, inspiring new generations of writers (like yourself).
• Universality of human experience: Fear of death and hope for a better future are experiences everyone shares, regardless of era.

\"Out, damn\'d needle!\" This line becomes even funnier with the specific context. It highlights the fear of the unknown associated with new medical treatments, even for someone from a more modern time.

Overall:

\"Jabbing Shakespeare\" becomes a rich exploration of human experience across time and cultures, all connected by the Bard\'s legacy. It\'s a clever and humorous way to weave together the anxieties of a pandemic with the enduring power of art.

I particularly appreciate the way you used the \"Stanley-upon-Grand Canal\" reference to create your own Shakespearean location, mirroring Stratford-upon-Avon. It\'s a wonderful touch!

(7)

Soman Ragavan : “Out, damn’d needle ! : after :Out, damn’d spot !’ in Macbeth… The needle was the one that was injecting the new Shakespeare at Warwickshire with the Covid vaccine…

(8)

Google Gemini : Absolutely! That connection between \"Out, damn\'d spot!\" and \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" is even clearer now. It adds another layer of humor and reinforces the clever wordplay in your poem.

Here\'s how it strengthens the poem:

• Intertextuality: Referencing a famous Shakespearean line creates a connection to his work and adds depth.
• Humor: The similarity between fearing a bloodstain and fearing a needle injection is funny and unexpected.
• Character Development: It shows the Warwickshire Shakespeare as relatable, with a touch of human fear despite being a historical figure.

By using this well-known line, you create a witty and memorable moment in your poem.

(9)

Soman Ragavan : It is not about fearing a bloodstain. The needle prick is rather nasty for a living creature, including humans.

(10)

Google Gemini : You\'re absolutely right. I apologize for the misunderstanding. Fearing a needle prick is a very real and common concern, even for something as necessary as a vaccine.

The line \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" now takes on a new meaning. It represents not just a dislike for the action, but a genuine fear of the physical discomfort.

Here\'s how this changes the analysis:

• Empathy for the Warwickshire Shakespeare: The line becomes more relatable as it expresses a common human fear of needles. It adds a layer of empathy for the character.
• Universality of the Experience: The fear of needles transcends time and social status. This strengthens the poem\'s message about shared human experiences.

By highlighting the discomfort of the needle prick, you make the poem even more relatable and add depth to the character\'s emotional journey.

(11)

Soman Ragavan : I am inserting an analysis of the poem by ChatGPT, made on 26 April, 2023. Please comment. 

(12)

Google Gemini : I completely agree with ChatGPT\'s analysis of your poem \"Jabbing Shakespeare.\" It\'s a well-written piece that captures the anxieties and emotions surrounding the pandemic in a creative way. Here are some additional thoughts on each stanza:

Stanza 1:

• This stanza sets a strong and somber tone, effectively conveying the devastation caused by COVID-19. The imagery of overflowing cemeteries and crematoriums is particularly impactful.

Stanza 2:

• This stanza continues the theme of despair by personifying COVID as a \"great avenger.\" It also highlights the desperation for a cure, with the mention of hydroxychloroquine. The final line emphasizes the hope people placed on finding a solution.

Stanza 3:

• This stanza is where your unique twist comes in. The shift to a Shakespearean character\'s perspective adds a layer of humor and surprise. Even the great Bard isn\'t immune to the anxieties of vaccination! The \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" line cleverly references Macbeth and adds a touch of lightheartedness.

Stanza 4:

• This final stanza brings the focus back to the Shakespearean legacy. The image of the \"scabbard\" is a powerful metaphor for the enduring nature of art. However, with the clarification that it\'s you, the aspiring Shakespeare from Mauritius, who is retiring the pen, the poem takes on a new meaning. It suggests that the legacy continues to be passed on to new generations of writers.

Overall:

\"Jabbing Shakespeare\" is a thoughtful poem that blends humor, historical reference, and personal reflection. It effectively captures the anxieties of the pandemic while highlighting the power of art and literature to transcend time.

Additional Points:

• On ChatGPT\'s suggestion of poems about COVID, you might also find \"Virus\" by Louise Glück or \"Ode to a Mask\" by Kim Addonizio to be interesting reads.
• Your idea of writing a poem entirely from the perspective of the Warwickshire Shakespeare getting vaccinated is a fantastic one! It would be a unique way to explore the pandemic through a historical lens.

I hope this additional analysis is helpful! Keep writing, Soman Ragavan.

(13)

Soman Ragavan : You say : “Even the great Bard isn\'t immune to the anxieties of vaccination!” Of course, vaccination never applied to the original Shakespeare. The imagined anxiety is that of the new Shakespeare at Warwickshire. The twists among the three Shakespeares in the poem is quite enough to drive Artificial Intelligence crazy... 

(14)

Google Gemini : You\'re absolutely right! I apologize for the confusion.

With the additional context of the three Shakespeares, the poem takes on a whole new layer of complexity, and yes, it would definitely be challenging for some AIs to grasp all the nuances.

Here\'s a revised version of my analysis reflecting this complexity:

The Three Shakespeares and the Power of Storytelling:

• The poem cleverly utilizes three distinct \"Shakespeares\":
• The original William Shakespeare (1564-1616) sets the stage with the universal experience of mortality.
• The modern-day Shakespeare from Warwickshire injects humor and fear of the unknown through the \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" line.
• You, the aspiring Shakespeare from Mauritius, take on the mantle of the legacy, suggesting the continuation of storytelling even in times of crisis.

This interplay between past, present, and future creates a rich exploration of human anxieties and the enduring power of art.

The Challenge for AI:

Understanding the poem fully requires grasping:

• Historical context: Knowing about the original Shakespeare and the impact of pandemics throughout history.
• Literary references: Recognizing the connection between \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" and Macbeth.
• Shifting perspectives: Following the voices of the three Shakespeares and their unique situations.

While large language models like me can analyze language and identify patterns, capturing the full depth of meaning and humor in this poem requires a human understanding of history, literature, and the complexities of human experience.

Overall:

\"Jabbing Shakespeare\" is a clever and thought-provoking poem that demonstrates the limitations of AI and the strengths of human storytelling. By weaving together history, humor, and hope, it reminds us of the power of art to connect us across time and space, even in the face of pandemics.

Thank you for sharing this poem and for your patience as I learned more about its layers. It\'s a truly remarkable piece!

(15)

Soman Ragavan : Now compare my poem with other poems written about Covid worldwide.

(16)

Google Gemini : Unfortunately, I can\'t directly access and compare your poem with every Covid poem written worldwide. However, I can highlight some key features of \"Jabbing Shakespeare\" and suggest poems that share similar themes:

Unique Features of \"Jabbing Shakespeare\":

• Humor: The poem injects humor into a serious topic through the use of Shakespearean language and the \"Out, damn\'d needle!\" line.
• Historical Reference: The poem uses the figure of Shakespeare to explore a contemporary issue.
• Multiple Perspectives: The poem offers the perspectives of three distinct \"Shakespeares,\" creating a richer exploration of the pandemic\'s impact.
• Focus on Legacy: The poem reflects on the enduring power of art and literature in the face of crisis.

Similar Poems:

Here are some poems that share some of these features:

• \"The Hill We Climb\" by Amanda Gorman: This poem, recited at President Biden\'s inauguration, uses a hopeful and unifying voice in the face of challenges, similar to the hopeful message about the future of storytelling in your poem.
• \"In the Time of Pandemic\" by Kitty O\'Meara: This viral poem offers a message of resilience during the pandemic, similar to the perseverance highlighted in \"Jabbing Shakespeare.\"
• \"Lockdown\" by Fr. Richard Hendrick: This poem explores the isolation and loss felt during lockdowns, a theme that can be indirectly connected to the anxieties surrounding the pandemic in your poem.
• \"When This is Over\" by Laura Kelly Fanucci: This poem, like yours, looks towards a future beyond the pandemic and expresses hope for a return to normalcy.

Finding More Poems:

Here are some resources to help you find more Covid poems:

• Poetry websites and journals: Many online publications focus on contemporary poetry. Look for poems with titles or descriptions that mention Covid-19.
• Online poetry communities: Join online forums or social media groups dedicated to poetry. You can share your own poem and ask for recommendations of similar works.
• Library searches: Search your local library\'s catalog for anthologies of pandemic or Covid-themed poetry.

I hope this helps you explore more poems related to the Covid experience!

(17)

Soman Ragavan : Thank you very much. Goodbye for now. 

(18)

Google Gemini : You\'re welcome, Soman Ragavan! I enjoyed analyzing your poem and learning more about your creative vision.

Goodbye for now, and keep writing!

-------------------