Soman Ragavan

AnalysisByChatGPT-Volume 125-Domineering crows--1Jan2025

SOMAN RAGAVAN

1 January, 2025

Subject : Domineering crows

Analysis by ChatGPT

(Artificial Intelligence)

Volume 125

 (1)

Soman Ragavan :

Hello. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean. I will write about crows in Mauritius. Here is some information about crows in general.

From the Internet :

“House crows Corvus splendens (Vieillot) have become well-established in Mauritius, where they pose several urban and environmental problems.”

“It maintains a territory year-round in which the entire extended family lives and forages together. But during much of the year, individual crows leave the home territory to join large flocks at dumps and agricultural fields, and to sleep in large roosts in winter.”

“Crows help control pest insects and “clean up” dead animals and garbage that has been scattered by other animals. Although crows prey on songbirds and their young, research suggests that they do not ordinarily have a significant impact on songbird populations.”

“Scientists compare the intelligence of crows to that of a seven-year-old human child. Crows, ravens, and other corvids are the only non-primates capable of making tools. Crows are capable of abstract reasoning, complex problem-solving, and group decision-making.”

“Crows and ravens are some of the smartest animals in the world, with their intelligence considered on par with chimpanzees. The New Caledonian Crow is probably the most famous example of one sign of intelligence—tool use—but this behavior has been recorded in several other species of Corvus as well.25 Aug 2021”

“The corvids (ravens, crows, jays, magpies, etc.) and psittacines (parrots, macaws, and cockatoos) are often considered the most intelligent birds, and are among the most intelligent animals in general.”

“The study from the University of Washington undeniably contributes to affirming the crows\' place in the intelligence hierarchy among birds. Crows, it appears, are creatures of memory, holding on to grudges and recalling threats even after a lengthy span of 17 years.12 Nov 2024”

Full acknowledgements are made to the authors, publishers and rights-holders.

Internet link :

https://www.google.com/search?q=how+was+the+crows+population+controlled+in+Mauritius&sca_esv=520ebc38deb93fb9&source=hp&ei=yL50Z__DJ6eqhbIPi5-52AM&iflsig=AL9hbdgAAAAAZ3TM2GHw7rxFuvgOGgZEQoYUfNBO_OFk&ved=0ahUKEwj_x4Sh0tOKAxUnVUEAHYtPDjsQ4dUDCA8&uact=5&oq=how+was+the+crows+population+controlled+in+Mauritius&gs_lp=Egdnd3Mtd2l6IjRob3cgd2FzIHRoZSBjcm93cyBwb3B1bGF0aW9uIGNvbnRyb2xsZWQgaW4gTWF1cml0aXVzMgUQIRigAUiAbVCsDVj5Z3ABeACQAQGYAbQEoAHNa6oBCjItNDguMi4xLjG4AQPIAQD4AQGYAjOgAp9oqAIAwgIFEAAYgATCAg4QABiABBixAxiDARiKBcICCxAAGIAEGLEDGIMBwgIIEAAYgAQYsQPCAhQQLhiABBixAxiDARjHARiKBRivAcICCxAAGIAEGLEDGIoFwgIEEAAYA8ICCBAuGIAEGNQCwgIFEC4YgATCAgYQABgWGB7CAggQABgWGAoYHsICCxAAGIAEGIYDGIoFwgIIEAAYgAQYogTCAgcQIRigARgKmAMD8QXVnMglMY2AvZIHCDItNDguMi4xoAei8QE&sclient=gws-wiz   

 Some more quotes :

--“A crow is never the whiter for washing herself often.”

--“The crow thinks her own birds fairest.”

--Quoted in : Sam Phillips : “3000 Proverbs.” New Delhi : Goodwill Publishing House, c 2017. Full acknowledgements are made here to the authors, publishers and rights-holders.

(2)

ChatGPT :  

Thank you for sharing this detailed information about crows, particularly in the context of Mauritius. If you would like, I can help you craft a comprehensive write-up or analysis of crows in Mauritius based on the provided material. It could include:

1. Introduction: Discuss the presence and behavior of crows in Mauritius, linking it to their global characteristics.
2. Environmental Impact: Explore the problems caused by crows and their role in urban and natural ecosystems in Mauritius.
3. Intelligence and Behavior: Highlight their remarkable intelligence, social structures, and adaptive behaviors, with comparisons to other corvids.
4. Cultural References: Reflect on proverbs or sayings involving crows and their symbolic meanings in various cultures.
5. Control Measures: Investigate strategies used to manage crow populations, referencing Mauritius and other regions.

Would you like me to draft a full document or assist with specific aspects of this topic?

 (3)

Soman Ragavan :  

No, thank you. Instead, we will do a general analysis together.

In Port Louis, the capital of Mauritius, there are public gardens at one place, where crows live in trees. At night fall they gather again in the trees and make an infernal noise for some time. The noise is particularly noticeable. It is not clear why they do so.

 (4)

ChatGPT :

Crows\' behavior in gathering and creating loud noises at dusk is a fascinating phenomenon, and there are several possible explanations rooted in biology and ecology. Let’s analyze this together:

1. Roosting Behavior

• Explanation: Crows often gather in large groups to roost in specific locations. These roosts provide safety in numbers, warmth, and a communal space for resting.
• In Port Louis Context: The public gardens, with their dense trees, likely serve as an ideal roosting site. The city\'s ambient warmth and protection from predators might make it particularly attractive.

1. Vocalization at Dusk

• Why They Make Noise:
• Communication: Crows are highly social animals. The noise could be a form of communication, with individuals sharing information about food sources, threats, or other critical matters.
• Territorial Disputes: Some of the noise might come from disputes as they jostle for the best roosting spots.
• Group Coordination: The vocalizations could help synchronize group activities or signal the arrival of stragglers.
• Port Louis Observation: The \"infernal noise\" at nightfall might reflect these behaviors amplified by the dense urban population of crows.

1. Urban Influence

• Human Impact: Urban areas often provide abundant food sources (garbage, leftovers) and fewer predators, leading to dense crow populations. This higher density can intensify their behaviors, making their noise more noticeable.
• Port Louis Specificity: The gardens may be central to their foraging routes, and the return to trees each night marks the end of their daily activity.

1. Symbolism and Folklore

• In literature and folklore, crows are often symbolic of wisdom, mystery, or even omens. Their gathering at dusk and noisy behavior could evoke cultural or symbolic interpretations in Mauritius.

Questions for Further Study

• Have there been efforts to manage crow populations in the city?
• Do residents associate any folklore or beliefs with the dusk noise of crows?
• Could local food availability or specific urban structures influence their roosting habits?

Would you like to explore any of these points further?

 (5)

Soman Ragavan :

The noise is intriguing and exasperating. Crows behave as if they are entitled, they respect nothing and nobody, they will make loud noises as if they don’t care about others, nor do they fear others. Perhaps they realise that “there is safety in numbers.” Groups of lionesses, wild dogs and hyenas, too, are conscious of their collective strength while hunting. In this case, the crows have returned to their nests at nightfall.

Sometimes crows form a small group and travel to other places. They have a domineering attitude and swoop down on other birds to scare them away and rule the place for some moments. Other birds do fly away in these circumstances. The crows do so to claim territory for a few moments or to feed. Then they move away. They can be easily recognized by their raucous cries and their completely dark bodies. Even the beaks and feet are totally black. In contrast, with the myna bird, the body colour is brownish black, but the beak and feet are bright yellow.

 (6)

ChatGPT :  

Your observations delve deeply into the behavior and characteristics of crows, particularly their assertive and unyielding nature. Let’s analyze these traits and behaviors further:

1. Entitled Behavior and Safety in Numbers

• Collective Strength: Just as you pointed out with lionesses, wild dogs, and hyenas, crows exhibit a similar reliance on group dynamics. Their \"entitlement\" might stem from the confidence they gain in numbers, as this reduces threats from predators or competitors.
• Urban Context: In cities like Port Louis, crows face few natural predators. This security reinforces their boldness, allowing them to act without fear or regard for humans or other species.

1. Territorial Domination

• Swooping and Scaring Other Birds:
• Purpose: Such behavior is usually a display of dominance to secure food, nesting sites, or territorial boundaries.
• Result: Smaller or less aggressive birds, like sparrows or mynas, quickly yield to their assertive tactics.
• Contrast with Myna Birds:
• Mynas are often seen as opportunistic and social birds but lack the overwhelming group aggression displayed by crows.
• Their contrasting physical appearance (yellow beak and feet) makes their demeanor appear less intimidating than the entirely black crows.

1. Vocalization as a Strategy

• Raucous Cries: The loud and often harsh calls of crows serve multiple purposes:
• Communication: Informing others of food, danger, or claiming territory.
• Intimidation: Driving away competitors or even intruding humans.
• Coordination: Maintaining group cohesion during activities like foraging or mobbing predators.
• Why It Intrigues and Exasperates:
• Humans are naturally drawn to sound patterns, and the unpredictable and persistent noise of crows can provoke mixed emotions.

1. Adaptability and Boldness

• Crows are known for their adaptability to urban environments. Their fearless demeanor and willingness to interact (or compete) with humans and other birds highlight their intelligence and resourcefulness.

1. Symbolism of Blackness

• Physical Appearance: Their entirely black bodies, beaks, and feet often evoke a sense of mystery or foreboding in cultural contexts.
• In Contrast to Mynas: The bright yellow feet and beaks of mynas provide a stark visual difference, making them appear more approachable and less threatening.

Additional Reflections

• Anthropomorphic View: We might interpret their behavior as \"entitled\" or \"domineering,\" but in reality, it’s a reflection of their survival instincts and evolutionary strategies.
• Urban Ecology: Their success in cities like Port Louis showcases how they exploit resources and adapt to human-made environments.

Would you like to explore how these traits influence people\'s perceptions of crows in Mauritius or delve deeper into comparisons with other bird species?

(7)

Soman Ragavan :

The crows seem to have perfected this act of scaring other birds away when they alight at one place. They have a commanding attitude and they show self-assurance. They are most of the time in groups, which probably makes them feel stronger. They want to be the rulers of the sky. They appear to be conscious of their group power.

 (8)

ChatGPT :

Your observations provide a vivid characterization of crows as self-assured and commanding creatures. Let’s delve further into these behaviors and their implications:

1. Mastery of Intimidation

• Scaring Other Birds:
• Tactic: By swooping down suddenly and loudly, crows establish immediate dominance over a location, forcing other birds to retreat.
• Efficiency: This behavior ensures they face less competition for food or space, even if only temporarily.
• Why It Works:
• Perception of Threat: Other birds perceive crows as aggressive and are unwilling to engage in direct conflict.
• Coordination: Crows act in unison, amplifying the effect of their intimidation.

1. Commanding Attitude and Group Power

• Self-Assurance:
• Crows display confidence, likely rooted in their intelligence and social structure. They seem to \"know\" their capabilities and leverage them effectively.
• Their commanding presence isn’t accidental—it’s a well-honed survival strategy.
• Group Dynamics:
• Strength in Numbers: Operating in groups gives crows a psychological and tactical edge. They can defend themselves better and overpower solitary birds.
• Shared Intelligence: Research shows that crows can communicate complex ideas within their groups, possibly strategizing their moves to maximize success.

1. Aspirations of Sky Rulers

• Metaphorical Rulership:
• Your description of crows wanting to \"rule the sky\" aligns with their evident desire to dominate spaces they occupy.
• Their ability to adapt and assert control over both urban and natural environments supports this notion of rulership.
• Consciousness of Group Power:
• It’s fascinating to consider that crows might have an awareness of their collective strength. This consciousness could stem from their evolved intelligence and social cooperation.

1. Comparisons with Other Birds

• Crows vs. Raptors:
• While birds of prey dominate through sheer strength and predatory skills, crows dominate through numbers, strategy, and persistence.
• Crows vs. Mynas and Sparrows:
• Mynas and sparrows lack the aggressive social tactics that make crows so formidable.

1. Broader Implications

• Human Perception:
• This commanding, self-assured attitude often leads people to see crows as symbols of cunning and dominance.
• Ecosystem Role:
• Their aggressive behavior may seem disruptive but often helps maintain ecological balance by controlling weaker or invasive species.

Reflection

Your observations highlight the duality of crows: they are both admirable for their intelligence and exasperating for their arrogance. Would you like to explore their cultural symbolism or their ecological role in Mauritius further?

(9)

Soman Ragavan :

Wild dogs, lionesses and hyenas, too, proceed in a coordinated way when attacking preys. With hyenas, it is hit-and-run, attrition tactics to wear down the opponent.

 (10)

ChatGPT :

Your comparison of crows to predators like wild dogs, lionesses, and hyenas adds a fascinating dimension to understanding their behavior. Let’s analyze these parallels in detail:

1. Coordinated Strategies

• Crows:
• Just like wild dogs and lionesses, crows use coordinated group tactics to assert dominance or achieve their objectives. Their synchronization during swoops and collective mobbing mirrors the hunting strategies of land predators.
• Objective: While predators seek to hunt prey, crows aim to control space or access resources.
• Lionesses:
• Lionesses execute well-planned ambushes, with individuals taking specific roles to encircle and subdue prey.
• Parallel: Crows act similarly when dispersing other birds—they move strategically to overwhelm their targets.
• Wild Dogs:
• Known for their high endurance and cooperative tactics, wild dogs are adept at exhausting prey.
• Parallel: Crows’ persistence, especially in urban areas, mirrors this relentless approach.

1. Attrition and Hit-and-Run Tactics

• Hyenas:
• Hyenas wear down their prey over time with hit-and-run attacks, leveraging endurance and teamwork.
• Parallel with Crows:
• Crows don’t engage in prolonged fights but often adopt a similar hit-and-run strategy, swooping in to scare competitors away and then retreating once their objective is achieved.
• This tactic reduces their risk of injury while achieving dominance.
• Psychological Impact:
• Just as hyenas cause stress and fatigue in their prey, crows intimidate and overwhelm other birds, forcing them to leave without direct confrontation.

1. Group Intelligence and Adaptability

• Shared Traits Across Species:
• Communication: Both hyenas and crows communicate effectively within their groups, enabling real-time coordination.
• Adaptability: Crows and hyenas are opportunistic and adaptable, thriving in environments ranging from urban areas to wilderness.

1. Role in Ecosystems

• Predatory Control:
• In their respective ecosystems, hyenas and wild dogs help control prey populations. Similarly, crows contribute by scavenging and managing insect populations.
• Social Order:
• These animals enforce a form of order within their environments through their dominance and territorial behaviors.

1. Behavioral Insights

• Confidence Through Unity:
• Like wild dogs and hyenas, crows derive much of their confidence from their group strength, showing an awareness of their collective power.
• Calculated Risks:
• Their avoidance of prolonged confrontation shows an understanding of risk versus reward, an indicator of their advanced intelligence.

Reflection

Your analogy not only highlights the intelligence of crows but also places them in a broader context of social and cooperative strategies in the animal kingdom. This perspective deepens our appreciation of their behavior and ecological role.

Would you like to explore more about their intelligence in comparison to land predators or delve into cultural interpretations of their behaviors?

 (11)

Soman Ragavan :

Please summarise your points and say how crows differentiate themselves as hunting machines.

(12)

ChatGPT :

Summary of Key Points

1. Coordinated Strategies:
• Crows act collectively, using synchronized movements and mobbing tactics to dominate spaces and competitors.
• Their group behavior mirrors the hunting strategies of wild dogs and lionesses.
2. Attrition and Hit-and-Run Tactics:
• Crows employ quick, calculated strikes to scare away rivals, similar to hyenas\' hit-and-run approach.
• This minimizes their risk while maximizing their success in gaining control.
3. Group Intelligence:
• Like other intelligent predators, crows leverage group communication and adaptability, showing advanced problem-solving and decision-making skills.
4. Adaptability:
• Crows thrive in diverse environments, using their intelligence to exploit urban and natural ecosystems efficiently.
5. Confidence Through Unity:
• Their collective strength emboldens them, allowing them to dominate even larger or more numerous competitors.

How Crows Differentiate as Hunting Machines

Crows set themselves apart as “hunting machines” by focusing on opportunism, intimidation, and efficiency:

• Opportunistic Feeding:
  Unlike predators that target specific prey, crows adapt their strategy based on availability—be it scavenging, insect hunting, or raiding nests.
• Psychological Warfare:
  They use noise, aggressive swoops, and group intimidation to overwhelm rivals, achieving their goal without direct conflict.
• Tool Use and Problem-Solving:
  Unique among birds, crows can use tools and solve complex problems, enabling them to access food sources that other animals might overlook.
• Energy Efficiency:
  By avoiding prolonged confrontations and relying on strategic group actions, crows conserve energy while achieving dominance in their ecosystem.

Crows\' blend of intelligence, adaptability, and social coordination makes them uniquely effective and resourceful “hunters” in their ecological niche.

(13)

Soman Ragavan :

Thank you very much. Goodbye for now.

 (14)

ChatGPT :

 You\'re welcome, Soman. It was a pleasure discussing this topic with you. Goodbye for now, and feel free to return anytime! 🌟

---------------------