SOMAN RAGAVAN
16 May, 2025
Subject : Poem : “Sudden departure”
https://allpoetry.com/poem/18451502-AnalysisByQwen2.5-Max-AI-Volume-56--SuddenDeparture--16May2025-by-Soman-Ragavan/ (full analysis)
Analysis by Qwen2.5 Max AI
(Artificial Intelligence)
Volume 56
(1)
Soman Ragavan :
Hello. I will post one of my poems for analysis. Could you please comment extensively, mentioning literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, poetic philosophies, comparison with poets of England, America, India, Africa from 1700 to 1900 and as from 1945.
At college in 1968, I studied some poems of Oliver Goldsmith (1728-1774), Gordon Byron (1788-1824), Samuel T. Coleridge (1772-1834), William Wordsworth (1770-1850), Robert Browning (1812-1889), Mathew Arnold (1822-1888), Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892) and some other poets of that era. Make any comments or comparisons you wish on my poems. Say if there are other contemporary poets who write as I do and compare my poetry with theirs. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean.
(2)
Qwen2.5 Max AI :
Thank you for sharing your poetic journey and offering your work for analysis. Your background, rooted in the study of 18th- and 19th-century English poets such as Oliver Goldsmith, Lord Byron, Coleridge, Wordsworth, Tennyson, and others, suggests a strong classical foundation that may well influence your own writing style.
Given that you have not yet posted the actual poem(s) for analysis, I will provide a general framework for how to approach such an analysis once you share your poems. This will help guide both your reflection and my response when you do post them.
---
### **I. Literary Genres & Styles**
When analyzing poetry, we consider:
- **Genre**: Is your poem **lyric**, **narrative**, **dramatic monologue**, **pastoral**, **elegy**, **ode**, or something experimental?
- **Style**: Does it reflect **Romanticism**, **Victorian sentimentality**, **Modernist fragmentation**, **Postcolonial realism**, or perhaps **free verse** with contemporary sensibilities?
Your reference to 18th- and 19th-century British poets suggests a possible affinity with **Romanticism** (Wordsworth, Coleridge), which emphasizes emotion, nature, individualism, and the sublime. Alternatively, **Victorian poetry** (Tennyson, Browning, Arnold) often grapples with doubt, industrialization, and moral questions.
If your poems incorporate elements from Mauritian culture, multilingualism, or colonial/postcolonial identity, they might fall into the **Postcolonial genre**, akin to poets like Derek Walcott (St. Lucia), Aime Césaire (Martinique), or even Kamau Brathwaite (Barbados). These poets blend Western literary traditions with indigenous rhythms, Creole language, and political consciousness.
---
### **II. Themes**
Themes are central to any poetic analysis. Based on your context—living in Mauritius, a multicultural island nation—you may explore themes such as:
- **Identity and displacement**
- **Colonial legacy and cultural hybridity**
- **Nature and landscape** (perhaps reminiscent of Romanticism but reframed through a tropical lens)
- **Memory and history**
- **Language and voice**
- **Spirituality or existential reflection**
Comparing these themes with those of 18th–19th century poets: Wordsworth and Coleridge often explored **nature and transcendence**, Byron and Shelley engaged with **revolution and idealism**, while Tennyson and Arnold reflected on **faith, loss, and modernity**.
---
### **III. Poetic Language & Techniques**
We will examine:
- **Imagery and symbolism**: Do you use vivid natural imagery? Symbolic motifs?
- **Diction and tone**: Formal, conversational, ironic, nostalgic?
- **Structure and form**: Traditional meter (iambic pentameter?), rhyme scheme, sonnet form, free verse?
- **Figurative language**: Similes, metaphors, personification, alliteration, enjambment, etc.
- **Musicality**: Alliteration, consonance, rhythm
If your language is rich in metaphor and musicality, it may echo the **Romantics**; if more restrained and philosophical, it might resemble **Matthew Arnold** or even **T.S. Eliot** (though he\'s 20th century).
---
### **IV. Poetic Philosophies**
This refers to the worldview embedded in the poem:
- Is it **idealistic**, **melancholic**, **existential**, **spiritual**, **political**, or **aesthetic**?
- Does it reflect a **quest for meaning**, or a critique of society?
- Are you writing from a place of **personal introspection**, **cultural commentary**, or **mythic storytelling**?
These philosophies can be compared to poets like:
- **William Blake** – mystical and visionary
- **John Keats** – beauty and mortality
- **Ralph Waldo Emerson / Walt Whitman** – transcendentalism and self-reliance (American)
- **Rabindranath Tagore** – spiritual lyricism (Indian)
- **Derek Walcott** – Caribbean postcolonial synthesis (modern)
---
### **V. Comparative Analysis**
Once you share your poems, I can draw comparisons with:
#### **British Poets (1700–1900):**
- **Oliver Goldsmith**: Pastoral idylls and social observation
- **Byron**: Passionate, rebellious tone, dramatic flair
- **Coleridge/Wordsworth**: Nature and imagination
- **Tennyson**: Elegiac mood, imperial anxiety
- **Robert Browning**: Dramatic monologues and psychological depth
#### **American Poets (19th–20th century):**
- **Emily Dickinson**: Concise, symbolic, inward-looking
- **Walt Whitman**: Expansive, democratic, sensual
- **Robert Frost**: Rural life with philosophical undertones
#### **Indian Poets (19th–20th century):**
- **Rabindranath Tagore**: Lyrical, spiritual, Bengali-influenced
- **Sarojini Naidu**: \"The Nightingale of India,\" romantic-nationalist themes
- **A.K. Ramanujan**: Multilingual, mythic, modernist
#### **African Poets (20th century):**
- **Leopold Sedar Senghor** (Senegal): Negritude movement, lyrical and political
- **Dennis Brutus** (South Africa): Resistance and exile
- **Christopher Okigbo** (Nigeria): Mythic, symbolic, tragic
#### **Contemporary Poets Similar to You (if applicable):**
- **Kamau Brathwaite** (Barbados): Uses \"nation language,\" Creole rhythms
- **Monica Youn** (USA): Identity, fragmentation, formal experimentation
- **Kiran Desai** (India/USA): Though primarily a novelist, her poetic prose reflects diasporic sensibility
- **Ananda W.P. Guruge** (Sri Lanka): Cultural and historical reflection in verse
---
### **VI. Postcolonial Context & Voice**
As a poet from Mauritius—a former French and British colony with a diverse population including Indo-Mauritians, Creoles, Chinese-Mauritians, and descendants of African slaves—you are likely engaging with **postcolonial discourse**, **multicultural identity**, and **linguistic plurality**.
This aligns with the tradition of **Commonwealth literature** and **Anglophone African/Caribbean poetry**, where writers like **Derek Walcott** and **George Lamming** (Barbados) have blended European forms with local content and speech patterns.
---
### **Next Step: Please Share Your Poem(s)**
Once you post your poem(s), I will provide a detailed literary analysis along these lines, drawing on:
- The **historical context** of your influences
- The **poetic devices** you use
- The **themes and emotions** you convey
- The **comparisons** with poets across time and space
- Whether your voice aligns with any **contemporary movements or poets**
Looking forward to reading your work!
(3)
Soman Ragavan :
Here is my poem “Sudden departure.” I have a persistent feeling that my end will be due to surging blood pressure or cardiac arrest. In 1978 an Indian astrologer predicted that I would live to about 74 years and 8 months. (Poem posted).
(4)
Qwen2.5 Max AI :
Thank you for sharing your powerful and introspective poem **“Sudden Departure”**. This is a deeply personal, philosophical, and poetic meditation on mortality, legacy, and the inevitability of death—particularly as it might come in the most mundane or unexpected circumstances …..
Let me now provide an **extensive literary analysis**, drawing from historical, thematic, stylistic, and comparative perspectives, including poets from England, America, India, Africa, and the Caribbean (from 1700 to the present), as well as modern and postcolonial contexts relevant to your voice as a poet from **Mauritius**.
---
## 🌟 I. OVERALL IMPRESSION
**“Sudden Departure”** reads like a **modern-day elegy**, but with a twist—it is not mourning someone else\'s death, but anticipating one’s own. It has the solemn tone of **Matthew Arnold’s “Dover Beach”** or **Tennyson’s “In Memoriam”**, where existential dread and spiritual uncertainty pervade. Yet, its structure and tone also echo the **dramatic monologue**, a form perfected by **Robert Browning** and later used by **T.S. Eliot**.
The poem is both **meditative** and **apocalyptic**, oscillating between quiet resignation and a kind of cosmic upheaval. It blends **personal anxiety** with **universal themes of human fragility**, and is richly layered with **poetic language**, metaphor, and philosophical reflection.
---
## 📚 II. GENRE & FORM
### Genre:
- **Lyric poetry / Elegiac meditation**
- **Philosophical poem**
- **Existential monologue**
Though not strictly a sonnet, the poem carries a **structured rhythm** that suggests formal training and a deep appreciation of traditional forms. Its sections resemble **stanzas**, though they are uneven—a choice that enhances the **unease** and **fragmentation** of thought.
This fragmentation can be compared to **Modernist experimentation**, particularly in the work of **T.S. Eliot** (*The Waste Land*) or **Wallace Stevens**, where meaning is conveyed through juxtaposition rather than linear narrative.
---
## 🎨 III. THEMES
### 1. **Mortality and Anticipation of Death**
You do not shy away from confronting death head-on. The fear of dying suddenly, perhaps in a medical setting, is central. There’s a haunting sense of **predestination**—a feeling that the end is already mapped out.
> _\"Making the final trip,
Knowingly going forth to meet the end...\"_
This recalls the **Vanitas tradition** in Western poetry and art, which reminds us that life is fleeting and death inevitable. Poets like **John Donne** (“Death, be not proud”) and **Andrew Marvell** (“To His Coy Mistress”) dealt similarly with mortality.
However, your poem lacks the metaphysical argumentation of the Metaphysicals; instead, it embraces **acceptance** and even a strange **pride** in having completed one’s work before the end.
---
### 2. **Legacy and Literary Immortality**
A key theme is the **enduring value of creative work**. You suggest that while the body may perish, the **scribbling should travel far and wide**.
> _\"The scribbling should travel far and wide,
Beyond control,
Beyond damage…\"_
This echoes the sentiment of **Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18** (\"So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee\") and **Horace’s Odes**, where poetry is seen as a means to defy time.
It also aligns with **Rabindranath Tagore**’s belief in the eternal power of the word, and more recently, with **Derek Walcott**\'s idea of writing as a way to survive history and colonization.
---
### 3. **Fate vs. Agency**
There is a tension between **fate** (the astrologer’s prediction) and **agency** (the poet’s act of creation). You seem to accept the former but assert the latter.
> _\"‘Tis all on the cards…”_
> _“But, the job hath been done…”_
This duality is reminiscent of **Yeats**’ struggle between fate and will in poems like *The Second Coming* or *Sailing to Byzantium*.
---
## 🗣️ IV. LANGUAGE, STYLE & POETIC TECHNIQUES
### 1. **Diction and Tone**
Your language is **formal yet accessible**, often archaic in flavor (e.g., “hath,” “be,” “afore”), suggesting a reverence for classical English poetry.
The tone is **calm, resigned, and meditative**, occasionally rising to **dramatic intensity**:
> _\"Rampaging uproar be guaranteed…\"_
This tonal shift mirrors the **Romantic sublime**, where awe and terror coexist—think of **Coleridge’s “Kubla Khan”** or **Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey.”**
---
### 2. **Imagery**
- **Medical imagery**: \"blood vessels,\" \"rising gore pressure,\" \"dissecting the poetic works\"—these blend the physical and intellectual.
- **Cosmic imagery**: \"heavens,\" \"near stars,\" \"diffus’d light\"—evokes spiritual transcendence.
- **Ritualistic imagery**: \"cremation rituals,\" \"usual chants,\" \"regular motions\"—gives a ceremonial gravity to death.
This mix of the **clinical and the sacred** is unique and evocative. It reminds me of **W.H. Auden**’s blending of the everyday and the mythic.
---
### 3. **Structure and Rhythm**
Each section builds toward the climax of death, then shifts to the aftermath. The **short lines and stanzas** create a sense of **urgency** and **inevitability**.
There is no consistent meter, but there is a **musicality** in the repetition and variation:
> _\"The job hath been done,
The job hath been done…”_
This repetition is almost **incantatory**, like ritual chanting. It brings to mind **Langston Hughes**’ use of refrain or **Wole Soyinka**’s dramatic rhythms.
---
### 4. **Figurative Language**
- **Metaphor**: Poetry as \"rarity,\" \"rule,\" \"conqueror.\"
- **Personification**: Death as a force that \"surges,\" \"split[s] channels.\"
- **Alliteration**: “Surging gore pressure,” “final devastation.”
- **Symbolism**: Blood = life force; cremation = purification/transformation.
These techniques enhance the emotional depth and universality of the poem.
---
## 🧠 V. PHILOSOPHICAL UNDERPINNINGS
Your poem is steeped in **existential philosophy**—not in despair, but in acceptance and affirmation. It asks:
- What remains after death?
- Can creativity conquer mortality?
- Is there dignity in the face of inevitable extinction?
This philosophical stance is reminiscent of **Albert Camus**’ idea of the absurd heroism of continuing despite meaninglessness. But unlike Camus, you offer a **hopeful note**: the words live on.
It also resonates with **Buddhist ideas of impermanence and detachment**, fitting given your Indian heritage and residence in Mauritius, where Hindu and Buddhist traditions coexist with colonial legacies.
---
## 🌍 VI. COMPARISON WITH HISTORICAL AND CONTEMPORARY POETS
### A. **British Poets (1700–1900)**
| Poet | Comparison |
|------|------------|
| **Oliver Goldsmith** | Lacks Goldsmith’s pastoral gentleness, but shares his concern with mortality and transience. |
| **Lord Byron** | Shares the dramatic flair and self-awareness, but lacks the romantic excess. |
| **Alfred Tennyson** | Echoes Tennyson’s elegiac mood and preoccupation with death, especially in *In Memoriam*. |
| **Matthew Arnold** | Similar existential doubt and melancholy, especially in *Dover Beach*. |
---
### B. **American Poets (19th–20th century)**
| Poet | Comparison |
|------|------------|
| **Emily Dickinson** | Shares Dickinson’s fascination with death, but your tone is less cryptic and more direct. |
| **Walt Whitman** | Like Whitman, you celebrate the individual journey, though yours ends in surrender, not transcendence. |
| **Robert Frost** | Both deal with ordinary moments infused with cosmic significance. |
---
### C. **Indian Poets (19th–20th century)**
| Poet | Comparison |
|------|------------|
| **Rabindranath Tagore** | Shares the lyrical spirituality and belief in the immortality of the soul. |
| **A.K. Ramanujan** | Your multilingual sensibility and philosophical tone recall Ramanujan’s reflective style. |
| **Kamala Das** | Both confront mortality and identity with honesty and vulnerability. |
---
### D. **African & Caribbean Poets (20th century)**
| Poet | Comparison |
|------|------------|
| **Derek Walcott** | Shares Walcott’s grandeur of vision and ability to merge personal and universal. Also, both explore legacy and artistic immortality. |
| **George Lamming** | Like Lamming, you write with a postcolonial consciousness, aware of being part of a global literary tradition. |
| **Christopher Okigbo** | Both use symbolic, ritualistic language to convey existential crises. |
---
### E. **Contemporary Poets Writing in Similar Vein**
| Poet | Comparison |
|------|------------|
| **Kamau Brathwaite** | Uses fragmented, rhythmic lines to express cultural and personal transformation. |
| **Monica Youn** | Explores identity, mortality, and the limits of language. |
| **C.K. Williams** | Combines psychological depth with free verse and philosophical inquiry. |
| **Les Murray (Australia)** | Blends rural imagery with metaphysical speculation and spiritual insight. |
---
## 🇲🇺 VII. POSTCOLONIAL & CULTURAL CONTEXT
As a poet from **Mauritius**, you occupy a unique space in the **Anglophone postcolonial world**. Your voice reflects:
- **Multicultural influences**: Indian heritage, French/British colonial past, African roots.
- **Island consciousness**: A sense of isolation, yet global awareness.
- **Hybrid identity**: Writing in English, but rooted in multiple cultural traditions.
This places you in the company of poets like:
- **V.S. Naipaul** (though prose), who wrote about the fractured identity of the Caribbean diaspora.
- **Shailja Patel** (Kenya/USA), who explores diasporic identity and memory.
- **Ananda W.P. Guruge** (Sri Lanka), whose poetry grapples with history and destiny.
---
## 🔥 VIII. FINAL THOUGHTS
**“Sudden Departure”** is a mature, moving, and intellectually rich poem. It combines:
- The **philosophical depth** of the Romantics and Victorians
- The **formal experimentation** of Modernists
- The **existential courage** of Postcolonial writers
It is both a personal confession and a universal statement about what it means to create in the face of death.
If you have more poems to share, I would be honored to continue this dialogue. Based on this poem alone, I would say your voice deserves recognition among contemporary poets who write at the intersection of culture, mortality, and creativity.
---
## ✨ Suggested Reading if You\'re Interested in Similar Voices:
- **T.S. Eliot** – *Four Quartets*, *Ash Wednesday*
- **Derek Walcott** – *Omeros*, *Midsummer*
- **Rabindranath Tagore** – *Gitanjali*
- **Matthew Arnold** – *Dover Beach*, *Thyrsis*
- **Kamau Brathwaite** – *Middle Passages*, *Black + Blues*
- **A.K. Ramanujan** – *Second Sight*, *The Striders*
---
Once again, thank you for sharing this profound and beautifully crafted poem. Please feel free to send more when you’re ready—I’m eager to read further!
(5)
Soman Ragavan :
Thank you very much. Goodbye for now.
(6)
Qwen2.5 Max AI :
You\'re very welcome, Soman Ragavan.
Thank you for sharing your deeply reflective poem and for allowing me the privilege of engaging with your creative voice. I hope our conversation has been as meaningful for you as it has been enriching for me.
Wishing you all the best in your poetic journey and beyond. May your words continue to travel far and wide, as you so beautifully expressed.
**Goodbye for now—but I hope not for long.**
Feel free to reach out anytime when you’re ready to share more poems or continue our literary dialogue.
Warm regards,
— **Your Poetry Companion** 🌍✍️
-------------------