Reply to A. E. Housman

jarcher54

Oh Shropshire Lad, look in my eyes, and

     tell me one more time

The glory and the fortune one gains

     dying in his prime--

 

To fling the heavy discus far

     but never hear its fall

To only know life's largest thrills

     and never feel the small--

 

Oh don't deny, my lightfoot lad

      Death was your greatest fear

So did you prove, avoiding it for

     For seventy-seven years!

 

  • Author: jarcher54 (Offline Offline)
  • Published: August 20th, 2023 10:53
  • Comment from author about the poem: Every poet should be at least lightly familiar with the lovely short poems of A E Housman, particularly the Shropshire Lad series in which the narrator ironically applauds the youthful athletic prowess of the lad and dismisses the idea of a long and dull life. https://mypoeticside.com/show-classic-poem-13496 The heroic lad that we know is headed to an early demise in the gory trenches of WWI. Housman himself lived a long and peaceful life. I wrote this in 1971, and but for a couple edits, have left it intact. I just stumbled on it and decided to share.
  • Category: Reflection
  • Views: 35
  • User favorite of this poem: aDarkerMind.
Get a free collection of Classic Poetry ↓

Receive the ebook in seconds 50 poems from 50 different authors


Comments12

  • orchidee

    Good write J.

  • sorenbarrett

    I am so glad that you decided to share this one. It reads so well and hits me deep. The second stanza grabbed me and said it all. I thank you for putting it in context with your note. It truly reads as a classic.

  • Doggerel Dave

    "should" - hasn't - will.
    Reflection? No, definitely a refutation.
    Which doesn't alter my intention as above.
    A smooth gem full of truth - Thanks.

    • jarcher54

      I think Housman knew he was being ironic... trying to make the best of it maybe? Thanks DD!

    • Jon Nakapalau

      Well done!

      • jarcher54

        Thank you sir! I have been too busy to check in much lately, so thanks for the incentive to peek in!

      • Neville


        I am delighted that you should honour said war poet .. I have long been a fan .. not only of him but of Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon and so very many others .. each one worthy of a read .. I am glad I passed by this way today my friend ... Neville

        • jarcher54

          There is something extra compelling about those fellows... having such a black world all around you, and losing friends and limbs and... sigh

        • aDarkerMind

          and what a share this is;
          a true work of art.

          • jarcher54

            Bene grazi'... the last line was a bit of black humor gone slightly askew... the middle stanza came out just right, but the ending could be reworked to be more.... serious?

          • hzugman

            Love it!

            • jarcher54

              Thanks! Your appreciation is a nice thing.

            • Bobby O

              I really like the piece, even more so after reading it’s history and appliqué .

              • jarcher54

                I'm more well-read than I am productive... I'm actually quite intimidated by all the great poets and writers of history, and by the better posters on MPS. Thanks for the comment...

                • Bobby O

                  Dig!
                  Your phrasing is in great order and in the spirit of metonymy , displayed with excellent exact placement

                • Norman Flagtea

                  I came across your poem only now and like it a lot!!
                  Please post some more,,

                • Quemis

                  Awesome!

                  Really love this one. The flow is perfect. Reminds me of a mix of Dahl and Robert Service.

                  Perfect, to the point. Funny.

                  • jarcher54

                    Yes, my scheme was to be somber and then hit with the punchline.

                    Great to hear from you old boy!

                  • Thomas W Case

                    Brilliant work. The theme resonates.

                  • Parisab

                    So exquisite! I also would like nothing more than your insight about the classics on this site…



                  To be able to comment and rate this poem, you must be registered. Register here or if you are already registered, login here.