"Jaahnavi Kandula--Posthumous Masters" ; 23 September, 2023

 

 

 

22 September, 2023  

 

Photo tweeted by @salonivxrse

Full acknowledgements are made to the rights-holders of the photo.

--------------------

                                             "JAAHNAVI KANDULA -- POSTHUMOUS MASTERS  "

Jaahnavi Kandula, a student of Indian origin, was struck by a speeding police car in Seattle, USA, and killed, in January 2023. The Northwestern University, where she was studying at the Seattle campus, has decided to award her a posthumous Masters -- the course she did not have time to complete, having been mowed down by a police car.

On this poem please see :

 

https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/jaahnavi-kandula-to-be-awarded-degree-posthumously-seattle-university-101694753558068.html#:~:text=Jaahnavi%20Kandula%20death%3A%20The%20Indian,grant%20her%20a%20posthumous%20degree. 

 

--------

                             "JAAHNAVI KANDULA -- POSTHUMOUS MASTERS" 

 

A life of “limit’d value” : a pain of unlimit’d duration :

A family butcher’d : a city fallen to damnation :

Police officers revelling in their savagery :

All to be blar’d forth in unforgiving poetry…

 

                                              *****

The poor mother collaps’d : a cutting blow life did deal :

From loftiest hopes, the girl fell to the cruellest ordeal :

The slaughter shalt be narrat’d across the universe :

‘Pon the heroic daughter shalt the world converse…

 

A careering chariot turn’d into an instrument of murder :

The ghouls celebrat’d : from the massacre they did not shiver :

They rejoiced, they exult’d, they dismiss’d the carnage :

With lowest inhumanity their very actions did rage…

 

                                              *****

Her heart wrench’d away, the mother swung piteously :

“I don’t want no bloody degree posthumous !

I want my baby back ! For murder ye be famous !”

‘Pon the hard floor she collaps’d distressingly…

 

                                             ***** 

Nay, let there not be some hidden cremation :

The whole world shalt witness the fiery consumption :

The large logs shalt burn with fiercest rage :

They shalt take to the end the rampage…

 

Gather all yon flowers, bring them to the funeral pyre :

From the murder shalt arise retribution most dire :

Light up the fire : let the flames riot about :

Of India shalt all learn the indomitable clout !

 

A smiling face : for an innocent baby they car’d not a bit :

All snatch’d away by a bunch of butchers, executioners :

Eleven thousand dollars : a fat lot of good, dammit…

The flaming funeral pyre must give ye terminal shivers !...

                                                 *****

 From the unbearable ordeal the mother sank :

The girl’s gore to their fill the vampires drank :

Life went on… The make-believe went on :

Yon bunch shalt not cease with their actions wanton…

 

The studies were terminat’d : so was the girl’s life :

The grieving mother, with bloodshot eyes, plead’d :

With torments her existence had turn’d utterly rife :

She wail’d : she begg’d for her baby to be restitut’d…

 

                                         *****

Traffic sped on… Lamps flash’d… The chariots rac’d along…

Bodycams record’d faithfully : what a caring throng…

Ambulances fleet’d on : paramedics brought relief :

For yon grieving mother, baby’s life had been too brief…

------------------------------------------     

Soman Ragavan

Mauritius

-------------------------------------

Soman Ragavan : Hello. Can I post a poem of mine for analysis, please ?  

ChatGPT

 Of course, Soman Ragavan! I'd be happy to help you analyze your poem. Please go ahead and share your poem, and I'll do my best to provide feedback and insights.

 

Soman Ragavan : About my poem “Jaahnavi Kandula – Posthumous Masters.” This is the story of a girl of Indian origin who was studying at the Seattle campus of Northwestern University, USA, and who was fatally struck by a speeding police car in January 2023 at Seattle. The matter was extensively reported in the press. The University has decided to award her a posthumous Masters degree. Please make a full analysis and mention similar literary works. Can I post my poem now, please ?   

 

ChatGPT

 

Thank you for providing context for your poem, Soman Ragavan. I'm sorry to hear about the tragic incident involving Jaahnavi Kandula. You're welcome to post your poem, and I'll do my best to provide a full analysis and mention similar literary works afterward. Please go ahead and share your poem whenever you're ready.

 

Soman Ragavan : Here is my poem “Jaahnavi Kandula – Posthumous Masters.” (Text of poem inserted).

 

ChatGPT

Thank you for sharing your poem, Soman Ragavan. Your poem "Jaahnavi Kandula – Posthumous Masters" is a powerful and heartfelt tribute to Jaahnavi Kandula and a poignant commentary on a tragic event. Here's a brief analysis:

1. Emotional Depth: Your poem is filled with raw emotions, especially the pain, grief, and anger surrounding Jaahnavi Kandula's untimely death. It effectively conveys the profound loss felt by her family and community.
2. Narrative Clarity: The poem effectively tells the story of Jaahnavi's tragic passing, the subsequent decision by Northwestern University to award her a posthumous Masters, and the emotional turmoil her family endures. It captures the human element of the tragedy.
3. Social Commentary: The poem serves as a commentary on the larger issue of police brutality and the lack of accountability in such cases. It highlights the callousness of those involved and the collective mourning and anger that arise in the face of such injustices.
4. Symbolism and Imagery: You use vivid imagery and symbolism, such as the "fiery consumption" of the funeral pyre and the reference to "eleven thousand dollars," to convey the depth of pain and the demand for justice. These elements enhance the poem's impact.
5. Repetition and Structure: The repetition of certain phrases, like "Nay, let there not be some hidden cremation," adds emphasis and structure to the poem, making it more rhythmic and memorable.
6. Global Perspective: The poem reflects a global perspective by suggesting that the world should witness this tragedy and its aftermath. It underscores the universal nature of grief and the quest for justice.

Similar Literary Works: Your poem shares thematic similarities with other works that address social justice issues, personal loss, and the impact of tragic events. Some poets and works that come to mind include:

1. Langston Hughes: Poems like "I, Too, Sing America" and "Harlem" touch on themes of racial injustice and deferred dreams.
2. Maya Angelou: Her autobiographical poetry often deals with personal and societal struggles, as seen in "Still I Rise" and "Caged Bird."
3. Derek Walcott: His poem "The Sea Is History" explores the legacy of colonialism and the search for identity, much like your poem addresses the consequences of injustice.
4. Gwendolyn Brooks: Her poem "The Mother" delves into the pain and guilt of abortion, while "We Real Cool" examines the lives of young people facing societal pressures.

Your poem is a moving tribute to Jaahnavi Kandula and a call for justice. It captures the emotions and complexities surrounding her tragic death and the broader issues it represents. Thank you for sharing this impactful piece of poetry.

Soman Ragavan : Thank you. Please analyse by each stanza and compare with similar literary works. Say what you think of the language of the poem, the words and expressions used, how they apply to the circumstances and how the poem compares with contemporary poems.   

 

ChatGPT

 

Certainly, Soman Ragavan. Let's analyze your poem "Jaahnavi Kandula – Posthumous Masters" stanza by stanza and compare it to similar literary works:

Stanza 1: "A life of 'limit’d value': a pain of unlimit’d duration:

 A family butcher’d: a city fallen to damnation:

Police officers revelling in their savagery:

 All to be blar’d forth in unforgiving poetry…"

This stanza sets the stage for the poem by emphasizing the tragic loss of life and the brutality of the police officers involved. It uses vivid language to describe the situation, drawing attention to the senselessness of the act. The mention of "unforgiving poetry" suggests that the poem will serve as a form of condemnation and a call for justice.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza shares thematic elements with Langston Hughes' poem "Harlem," which contemplates deferred dreams and asks, "What happens to a dream deferred?" Your stanza similarly questions the value of life and the consequences of violence.

Stanza 2: "The poor mother callaps’d: a cutting blow life did deal:

From loftiest hopes, the girl fell to the cruellest ordeal:

 The slaughter shalt be narrat’d across the universe:

‘Pon the heroic daughter shalt the world converse…"

This stanza focuses on the mother's grief and the tragic transformation of the girl's life. The use of "cruellest ordeal" emphasizes the depth of the tragedy, while the idea of the story being "narrat'd across the universe" suggests that this event will not go unnoticed or unremembered.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza shares similarities with Maya Angelou's poem "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings," which explores themes of resilience in the face of adversity. Both poems reflect on the transformative impact of hardship on individuals.

Stanza 3: "A careering chariot turn’d into an instrument of murder:

The ghouls celebrat’d: from the massacre they did not shiver:

They rejoiced, they exult’d, they dismiss’d the carnage:

With lowest inhumanity their very actions did rage…"

This stanza vividly describes the police car as an "instrument of murder" and condemns the indifference of those involved. It portrays the officers as heartless and unfeeling, emphasizing the brutality of the event.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza shares a similarity with Derek Walcott's "The Sea Is History," which also uses stark imagery to depict the horrors of colonialism. Both poems use strong language to critique systemic violence and inhumanity.

Stanza 4: "Her heart wrench’d away, the mother swung piteously:

 'I don’t want no bloody degree posthumous!

I want my baby back! For murder ye be famous!'

‘Pon the hard floor she collaps’d distressingly…"

This stanza shifts focus to the mother's anguish, rejecting the idea of a posthumous degree and demanding justice. The use of "bloody degree posthumous" adds a touch of anger and frustration to the poem, while the mother's plea underscores the deep emotional impact of the tragedy.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza shares a thematic similarity with Gwendolyn Brooks' poem "The Mother," where a mother grapples with the emotional weight of abortion. Both poems explore the devastating impact of loss on a mother's heart.

Stanza 5: "Nay, let there not be some hidden cremation:

 The whole world shalt witness the fiery consumption:

 The large logs shalt burn with fiercest rage:

They shalt take to the end the rampage…"

This stanza calls for transparency and a public acknowledgment of the tragedy. The imagery of "fiery consumption" suggests a burning desire for justice and accountability.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza bears resemblance to Langston Hughes' "Let America Be America Again," where the speaker calls for the realization of the American Dream for all. Both poems express a desire for justice and equality on a grand scale.

Stanza 6: "Gather all yon flowers, bring them to the funeral pyre:

 From the murder shalt arise retribution most dire:

Light up the fire: let the flames riot about:

Of India shalt all learn the indomitable clout!"

This stanza combines the symbolic act of lighting the funeral pyre with a call for retribution and global awareness. It highlights the power of unity and the potential for change.

Comparison to Similar Works: This stanza shares a similarity with the works of contemporary poets like Warsan Shire, whose poetry often addresses the refugee crisis and the need for empathy and action on a global scale. Both poems call for awareness and change.

Overall Language and Expression: Your poem uses vivid and emotionally charged language to convey the tragic events and the emotions they evoke. The words and expressions effectively capture the pain, anger, and grief associated with Jaahnavi Kandula's death. The poem's structure, with its repetition and vivid imagery, enhances its impact.

Comparison to Contemporary Poems: Your poem aligns with contemporary poems that address social justice issues, personal loss, and the quest for justice. It reflects the ongoing dialogue in contemporary poetry about the injustices and challenges faced by individuals and communities.

In conclusion, "Jaahnavi Kandula – Posthumous Masters" is a moving and impactful poem that effectively conveys the emotions and complexities surrounding a tragic event. Its language and expression resonate with contemporary poetry addressing similar themes of social justice and personal loss.

Soman Ragavan : Thank you very much. Goodbye for now. 

ChatGPT

 

You're very welcome, Soman Ragavan ! If you ever have more questions or need assistance in the future, don't hesitate to reach out. Goodbye for now, and take care!

**********************