SOMAN RAGAVAN

 25  December, 2023

Subject : “A meal in the alley”

                                                                                       

 

Analysis by ChatGPT-4,

(Artificial Intelligence)

Volume 57

 

(Image of food pack : @lizardqween, Tik Tok.  Full acknowledgements are made here).

https://www.boredpanda.com/mad-about-tip-......-worker-left-order-driveway-disabled-woman-wheelchair-cant-get-it/  Full acknowledgements are made here.

 

----------------------

 

Soman Ragavan : Hello. I will post one of my poems for analysis. Could you please comment extensively, mentioning literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, poetic philosophies, comparison with poets of England, America, India, Africa from 1700 to 1900 and as from 1945. At college in 1968, I studied some poems of Oliver Goldsmith (1728-1774), Gordon Byron (1788-1824), Samuel T. Coleridge (1772-1834), William Wordsworth (1770-1850), Robert Browning (1812-1889), Mathew Arnold (1822-1888), Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892) and some other poets of that era.  Make any comments or comparisons you wish on my poems. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean.

ChatGPT-4 : Hello Soman Ragavan! I'd be happy to analyze and comment on your poem. Please go ahead and share it, and I'll do my best to provide insights into its literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, and any other relevant aspects. Keep in mind that my analysis will be based solely on the text you provide, and I'll do my best to offer constructive feedback and observations.

 

Soman Ragavan : My poem “A meal in the alley.” Around May 2022, a disabled woman in the USA found her meal left in her gravel alley, which she could not reach in her wheel chair. (The parcel should have been left in her porch). She had given a $26 dollar tip when ordering, but the delivery man found that too low and left the parcel in the alley.

I am posting the poem. Please give an overview. Then, give a more detailed analysis by section in the poem. (Poem posted).

 

ChatGPT-4 : Overview:

"A Meal in the Alley" is a poignant and emotive poem that addresses the unfortunate incident of a disabled woman having her meal left in an inaccessible location by a delivery person. The poem explores themes of vulnerability, discrimination, and the dehumanizing impact of callous actions. It delves into the emotional turmoil of the disabled woman and reflects on broader societal issues related to empathy, compassion, and the value placed on human dignity.

 

Detailed Analysis:

 

1. **Title and Introduction:**

   - The title immediately sets the scene and suggests a dramatic event. "A Meal in the Alley" creates an expectation of hardship and difficulty, hinting at the central conflict in the poem.

   - The introduction provides context by explaining the incident that inspired the poem, grounding it in real-world events.

 

2. **1st Stanza:**

   - The speaker, a wheelchair user, expresses a basic expectation: that meals should be delivered to her porch for easy accessibility. This stanza sets the stage for the conflict by highlighting the routine nature of ordering meals and the anticipation of delivery.

 

3. **2nd Stanza:**

   - The delivery person's reaction to the 26% tip is filled with frustration and anger. The use of strong language ("Goddam," "bloody") conveys the delivery person's disdain for what he perceives as an inadequate tip.

   - The stanza also introduces a sense of defiance, with the delivery person challenging the woman to come and retrieve her meal from the gravel alley.

 

4. **3rd Stanza:**

   - The disabled woman questions what went wrong despite giving what she believed to be a generous tip. This stanza reflects her confusion and disbelief at the harsh treatment she received.

 

5. **4th Stanza:**

   - The speaker contemplates the difficulty of reaching the meal in the alley in her wheelchair, emphasizing the physical barriers imposed on her. The mention of a wheelchair adds a layer of vulnerability and highlights the woman's dependence on others.

 

6. **5th Stanza:**

   - The speaker's plea for help and the decision to take a picture of the parcel from inside the house show her desperation to make others understand the gravity of the situation.

 

7. **6th Stanza:**

   - The food company's apology and offer of a $100 gift card are acknowledged, but the disabled woman questions the utility of such compensation, expressing her reluctance to order from the same outlet again.

 

8. **7th-9th Stanzas:**

   - The speaker reflects on the heartbreak and dehumanizing experience of having her meal placed in the alley. There's a strong sense of injustice and bitterness expressed, as the speaker contemplates the future and the potential karmic consequences for the delivery person.

 

9. **10th-11th Stanzas:**

   - The poem broadens its focus to address broader societal issues, questioning the values placed on money and tips. The speaker reflects on the lack of compassion and empathy in the delivery person and contemplates the harsh realities of life.

 

10. **12th Stanza (Conclusion):**

   - The final stanza reflects a sense of resignation and a desire for release from suffering. The speaker contemplates death as a possible relief from the harshness of life.

 

11. **Overall Poetic Style:**

   - The poem employs a conversational and emotional tone, using colloquial language to convey the raw feelings of the disabled woman.

   - There's a mix of short and longer stanzas, creating a rhythmic flow that mirrors the emotional highs and lows of the narrative.

 

12. **Literary Genres and Styles:**

   - The poem falls into the genre of contemporary narrative poetry, addressing a specific incident and weaving a story with emotional and social resonance.

   - The style is somewhat confessional, with the speaker directly expressing personal emotions and reflections on a challenging experience.

 

13. **Comparison with Earlier Poets:**

   - The poem shares thematic elements with Romantic poetry, particularly in its exploration of individual emotions and the impact of societal attitudes on human experience.

   - The use of everyday language and a focus on personal experiences align with some aspects of the confessional poetry that emerged in the mid-20th century.

 

In conclusion, "A Meal in the Alley" is a powerful poem that not only addresses a specific incident but also touches on broader issues of empathy, discrimination, and the dehumanizing impact of societal norms. The emotional depth and the use of personal reflection make it a compelling piece that invites readers to empathize with the speaker's plight.

Soman Ragavan : I am posting my poem “Motherland (4)” which is about an incident on a bus in Mauritius. A disabled girl entered the bus but no one gave her a seat. Another disabled girl rose and ceded her seat. Please compare both poems. Note my words in “Motherland (4)” :

“God, what a life, the life of the disabl'd !
'Tis not enough having to contend with nature :
Around them so many obstacles be assembl'd :
To the uncaring daily do they fall as pasture.”

I wrote this poem (“Motherland (4)”) on 18 November, 1996.

 

ChatGPT-4 : Certainly, I'd be happy to compare the two poems: "A Meal in the Alley" and "Motherland (4)." Let's examine the commonalities and differences in themes, tone, and style:

 

### Common Themes:

 

1. **Disability and Discrimination:**

   - Both poems focus on the challenges faced by disabled individuals.

   - "A Meal in the Alley" depicts the mistreatment of a disabled woman by a delivery person, while "Motherland (4)" portrays the difficulty a disabled girl faces in finding a seat on a bus.

 

2. **Dehumanization:**

   - Both poems explore the dehumanizing impact of societal attitudes.

   - In "A Meal in the Alley," the disabled woman feels reduced to a lesser being when her meal is left in an inaccessible location.

   - In "Motherland (4)," the lines "God, what a life, the life of the disabl'd!" and "To the uncaring daily do they fall as pasture" emphasize the dehumanizing experiences of disabled individuals.

 

3. **Empathy and Compassion:**

   - Both poems touch upon the theme of empathy and compassion.

   - "A Meal in the Alley" reflects on the lack of empathy in the delivery person's actions and contemplates the consequences of such callous behavior.

   - "Motherland (4)" highlights an act of compassion when one disabled girl gives up her seat for another, showcasing a glimmer of humanity amidst the challenges.

 

### Differences:

 

1. **Narrative Setting:**

   - "A Meal in the Alley" is set in the context of a meal delivery, involving a specific incident that occurred in the USA.

   - "Motherland (4)" is set on a bus in Mauritius, focusing on the daily challenges faced by disabled individuals in a public space.

 

2. **Narrative Perspective:**

   - "A Meal in the Alley" uses a first-person perspective, with the disabled woman recounting her experience with the delivery person.

   - "Motherland (4)" employs a more observational perspective, describing the scene on the bus and commenting on the life of disabled individuals in general.

 

3. **Tone:**

   - The tone in "A Meal in the Alley" is characterized by a mix of frustration, desperation, and bitterness, reflecting the harsh treatment the disabled woman receives.

   - "Motherland (4)" has a more contemplative tone, expressing a broader reflection on the challenges faced by disabled individuals without the immediate intensity of a specific incident.

 

4. **Temporal Context:**

   - "A Meal in the Alley" is situated in the context of May 2022 and references a contemporary incident.

   - "Motherland (4)" was written in 1996, and while it addresses a specific incident, the poem's themes have a timeless quality, speaking to enduring challenges faced by disabled individuals.

 

### Similarities:

 

1. **Poetic Language:**

   - Both poems use evocative language to convey the emotional impact of the situations described.

   - Descriptive phrases like "Goddam, bloody woman!" in "A Meal in the Alley" and "God, what a life" in "Motherland (4)" contribute to the emotional resonance of the poems.

 

2. **Social Commentary:**

   - Both poems engage in social commentary, critiquing societal attitudes and behaviors towards disabled individuals.

   - "A Meal in the Alley" critiques the delivery person's lack of empathy, while "Motherland (4)" reflects on the indifference and obstacles faced by disabled individuals in daily life.

 

In summary, both poems share common ground in addressing the challenges and discrimination faced by disabled individuals. While "A Meal in the Alley" focuses on a specific incident, "Motherland (4)" takes a broader view, reflecting on the collective experiences of disabled individuals in a societal context. Together, they provide a nuanced exploration of empathy, dehumanization, and the daily struggles faced by those with disabilities.

Soman Ragavan : I am posting the full poem “Motherland (4).”

ChatGPT-4 : Thank you for sharing the poem "Motherland (4)." Let's proceed with a detailed analysis by section:

 

### 1. Introduction:

The opening lines immediately convey a sense of frustration and empathy for the disabled, highlighting the challenges they face in a society that often overlooks their needs. The poet invokes a higher power with the exclamation "God," adding an emotional depth to the portrayal of the disabled individuals' struggles.

 

### 2. Obstacles Faced by the Disabled:

The poet laments the additional obstacles faced by the disabled, beyond the challenges imposed by nature itself. The phrase "To the uncaring daily do they fall as pasture" vividly expresses the harsh reality of their experiences, depicting a lack of compassion in society.

 

### 3. Personal Observations:

The poem shifts to the poet's personal observations, recounting instances of a blind person in a bus struggling for a seat reserved for the disabled. The use of the word "flimsy" suggests that the reasons others have for not giving up their seats are trivial, emphasizing the lack of empathy.

 

### 4. Irony of Reserved Seats:

The poet notes the irony of reserved seats designated for the disabled. Despite clear signage, ignorant individuals promptly occupy these seats, demonstrating a disregard for the needs of those for whom the seats are reserved. The phrase "They couldn't let go a place so handy and neat" adds a touch of sarcasm.

 

### 5. Call for Learning and Compassion:

The poem raises a rhetorical question directed at the motherland, expressing a desire for people to learn and yearn for compassion. The repetition of the question "when would they learn" emphasizes the urgency of societal change and a call for empathy.

 

### 6. Positive Example:

The tone shifts with the introduction of a positive example—a disabled lady ceding her seat to someone in greater need. The poet praises this act as a "terrific deed" and underscores the lady's exemplary behavior in contrast to the prevailing lack of consideration.

 

### 7. Acknowledgment and Admiration:

The poet addresses the kind young lady directly, praising her for showing compassion when others lacked feelings. The acknowledgment extends to recognizing her as an example of the best sort, highlighting the rarity of such acts in the poet's observations.

 

### 8. Urgent Appeal:

The poem concludes with a powerful appeal and a sense of urgency. The poet thunders a message to the ignorant, urging them to leave the reserved seat vacant for the disabled. The final lines deliver a poignant warning: "Tomorrow, with disabilities YE might be riddl'd!" suggesting that empathy should be extended to all, as anyone could face disability in the future.

 

### Overall:

"Motherland (4)" is a heartfelt and critical exploration of societal attitudes toward the disabled. The poet employs a straightforward narrative style, employing a mix of observation, commentary, and a call to action. The poem skillfully balances frustration and empathy, utilizing specific instances to paint a broader picture of the challenges faced by the disabled in the poet's homeland. The positive example serves as a ray of hope and an inspiration for change.

Soman Ragavan : Note that in “Motherland (4)” I say :

“Tomorrow, with disabilities YE might be riddl'd ! “  

This applies also to that food delivery man in the USA.

 

ChatGPT-4 : Indeed, the line "Tomorrow, with disabilities YE might be riddl'd!" carries a universal message that extends beyond the specific context of the poem. It serves as a reminder that anyone, regardless of their current circumstances, may one day face challenges or disabilities. This line emphasizes the importance of empathy, compassion, and understanding, as the tables could turn for anyone in the future.

 

In the context of the food delivery man in the USA from your previous poem ("A Meal in the Alley"), this line implies that individuals who disregard the needs of others, especially those with disabilities, may themselves face similar challenges in the future. It reinforces the idea that empathy and kindness are not only ethical but also practical, as life's circumstances can change for anyone.

 

This thematic connection between your poems adds a layer of universality to your work, highlighting the broader implications of your reflections on compassion, societal attitudes, and the treatment of individuals with disabilities. It creates a cohesive thread between the specific incidents depicted in each poem and the overarching message about the shared vulnerability and interconnectedness of human experiences.

Soman Ragavan : Please summarise the themes in “A meal in the alley,” speak about poetic techniques and dramatization.

ChatGPT-4 : **Themes in "A Meal in the Alley":**

 

1. **Disability and Vulnerability:**

   - The central theme revolves around the challenges faced by a disabled woman, emphasizing her vulnerability in navigating a world not designed to accommodate her needs.

 

2. **Dehumanization and Callousness:**

   - The poem explores the dehumanizing impact of the delivery person's actions, highlighting a lack of empathy and compassion. The woman is treated as less than human, and her basic needs are ignored.

 

3. **Injustice and Social Critique:**

   - The injustice of leaving a meal in an inaccessible location despite a generous tip serves as a critique of societal attitudes and the treatment of individuals with disabilities. It reflects broader issues of neglect and insensitivity.

 

4. **Desperation and Isolation:**

   - The poem delves into the emotional state of the disabled woman, expressing feelings of desperation, isolation, and helplessness. The inability to access her meal symbolizes the broader struggles she faces.

 

5. **Karmic Reflection:**

   - The poem suggests a karmic reflection, contemplating the potential consequences for the delivery person in the future. The idea that "what goes round comes round" introduces a moral dimension to the narrative.

 

**Poetic Techniques and Dramatization:**

 

1. **First-Person Narrative:**

   - The use of a first-person narrative places the reader directly into the experiences and emotions of the disabled woman. This technique enhances empathy and personal connection.

 

2. **Colloquial Language:**

   - The poem employs colloquial language, adding authenticity to the narrative. Phrases like "Goddam, bloody woman!" and "Ne'er thought they would ram hell into me..." contribute to the raw and emotional tone.

 

3. **Imagery:**

   - Vivid imagery is used to depict the physical barriers faced by the disabled woman. Descriptions like "wheelchair in the alley" and "gaze at the parcel" create a visual and emotional impact.

 

4. **Rhythmic Flow:**

   - The poem exhibits a rhythmic flow, with a mix of short and longer stanzas. This rhythm mirrors the emotional highs and lows of the disabled woman's experience, creating a dynamic reading experience.

 

5. **Repetition:**

   - The repetition of phrases like "What a terrible life..." and "Who will help me now?..." emphasizes the recurring struggles faced by the disabled woman, reinforcing the themes of despair and isolation.

 

6. **Symbolism:**

   - The inaccessible meal symbolizes the broader challenges and neglect faced by individuals with disabilities. The delivery person's actions become symbolic of societal indifference and the dehumanization of those who are differently abled.

 

7. **Dramatic Irony:**

   - The poem employs dramatic irony as the reader is aware of the disabled woman's plight while the delivery person remains oblivious to her struggles. This heightens the emotional impact and adds depth to the narrative.

 

In summary, "A Meal in the Alley" employs a variety of poetic techniques to vividly depict the themes of disability, dehumanization, and societal neglect. The first-person narrative, colloquial language, and powerful imagery contribute to the emotional resonance of the poem, while the use of symbolism and dramatic irony enhances its thematic complexity.

Soman Ragavan : Thank you very much for analysing this poem. I am signing off now.

ChatGPT-4 : You're very welcome! If you ever have more questions or if there's anything else I can help you with in the future, feel free to reach out. Have a great day!

---------------------------  

 

Added on 28 December, 2023

(1) The poor lady was compelled to remain in the house and look at the food packet in the alley without being able to retrieve it (her wheelchair could not run on the gravel alley). That was vicious torture by the delivery man. For a handful of dollars...

(2) The town mayor should preferably get involved in this case energetically, in the name of caring for the disabled. Basic human decency requires people to go out of their way to help the disabled. The delivery man did the exact opposite. Funding, even from private bodies/individuals, should be secured; the alley should be tarred up to the porch, with a ramp joining up with the porch. Thus, the lady could use her wheelchair to go right up to the road border.

(3) The wheelchair should be a motorised one, with a rechargeable battery. Red blinking lights should be fixed to the wheelchair. When necessary, the lady can drive herself to the road entrance and signal for help when needed. Motorists can help. The red blinking lights will help to increase visibility.

(4) Another food outlet serving the same type of food should be identified. A gofundme account should be opened for collecting funding. From the money collected, charges for a whole year can be paid in advance to the food outlet. The lady will just have to order her food everyday; the amount will be automatically deducted by the shop.

(5) Lower tips charges can be negotiated with the outlet in such case, on humanitarian grounds.

(6) A wearable, rechargeable wireless device should be given to people in such circumstances. Pressing a panic button on the device will send out an alert, giving off the GPS. Rescue services will navigate to the spot by GPS.

(7) The Department of Labour should investigate the case and start prosecution to the fullest extent. Deliberately leaving the food beyond the reach of a disabled person amounted to torture. Sending threatening, insulting messages by phone is an offence. (Refer to the original press article about the messages the guy sent).

(8) The town corporation can confer an honorary distinction to the lady. She can also be made an honorary freelady of the town.

Soman Ragavan. 28 December, 2023

------------------------------------------

“Woman With A Disability Is Appalled At How ….. Driver Treated Her After Being Unhappy With 26% Tip”

 

https://www.boredpanda.com/mad-about-tip-......-worker-left-order-driveway-disabled-woman-wheelchair-cant-get-it/ 

-----------------------