AnalysisByChatGPT-Volume 103-The auction--31July2024

SOMAN RAGAVAN

31 July, 2024

Subject : Analysis of the poem “The auction.”

Analysis by ChatGPT

(Artificial Intelligence)

Volume 103

Soman Ragavan : Hello. I will post one of my poems for analysis. Could you please comment extensively, mentioning literary genres, styles, themes, poetic language, poetic philosophies, comparison with poets of England, America, India, Africa from 1700 to 1900 and as from 1945.

At college in 1968, I studied some poems of Oliver Goldsmith (1728-1774), Gordon Byron (1788-1824), Samuel T. Coleridge (1772-1834), William Wordsworth (1770-1850), Robert Browning (1812-1889), Mathew Arnold (1822-1888), Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892) and some other poets of that era.  Make any comments or comparisons you wish on my poems. Say if there are other contemporary poets who write as I do and compare my poetry with theirs. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean.  

(2)

ChatGPT :

Hello, Soman Ragavan. I'm looking forward to reading and analyzing your poem. Please go ahead and upload your Word file with the poem, and I'll provide an extensive commentary as requested.

(3)

Soman Ragavan :

My poem “The auction.” During colonial times in India, at one point the English wanted to demolish the Taj Mahal and sell off the marble blocks to raise money for running the country. Bentinck was Governor General. A test auction had even been made, but the response was poor. The idea was abandoned. Here is my poem. Please make a full analysis.

“…There were other reasons which account for the success  of the "Anglicists". For the  quarter of a century which preceded the Mutiny, although much of the country was settled, the administration remained chiefly occupied in minor wars, and the pacification of new territory. The Government was  continually short of money and obsessed with the idea of building up a prosperous country upon the ruins of the old anarchy. It was typical of these times that Bentinck as Governor-General should have seriously considered the demolition of the Taj Mahal and the sale of its marble. He "was only diverted because the test auction of materials from the Agra Palace proved unsatisfactory." {E. B. HAVELL : "INDIAN SCULPTURE AND PAINTING." Page 246}.  "THE LEGACY OF INDIA." (Edited by G. T. Garratt). Introduction by the Marquess of Zetland. Oxford : The Clarendon Press, 1937. (P : 401, 402). Full acknowledgements are made to the authors, publishers and rights-holders. (Poem posted).

(4)

ChatGPT :

### Analysis of "The Auction" by Soman Ragavan

**1. Literary Genres and Styles**

"The Auction" can be classified as a satirical poem with elements of historical narrative. Satire is evident in the mocking tone used to criticize the colonial mindset and the absurdity of attempting to demolish a cultural monument like the Taj Mahal for financial gain. The poem employs a narrative style, recounting an incident from colonial history with a fictionalized monologue from the perspective of British colonizers.

**2. Themes**

- **Colonial Arrogance and Disrespect:** The poem criticizes the colonial administration's disrespect for Indian culture and heritage, as seen in their consideration of demolishing the Taj Mahal.

- **Cultural Ignorance:** It highlights the ignorance of colonial rulers towards the significance of local traditions and monuments, treating them merely as resources for exploitation.

- **Materialism vs. Cultural Value:** The poem contrasts the materialistic perspective of the colonizers with the cultural and historical value of the Taj Mahal.

- **Frustration with Colonial Rule:** The poem also conveys the frustration and disdain of the British rulers towards the colonized population, whom they view as uncivilized.

**3. Poetic Language and Devices**

- **Irony:** The poem is rich with irony, particularly in the colonizers' dismissal of the Taj Mahal as a "sinister construction" and their failure to appreciate its beauty and cultural importance.

- **Colloquial Language and Diction:** The use of colloquial British expressions ("bloody hell," "damn thing," "goddamn") adds authenticity to the colonial voice and emphasizes their casual disregard for Indian heritage.

- **Mockery and Sarcasm:** The poem uses mockery, especially in describing the Taj Mahal as a "monument of a loony," to emphasize the absurdity of the colonial viewpoint.

- **Imagery and Symbolism:** The Taj Mahal is symbolically portrayed as a "silly mausoleum" and a "stupid edifice," contrasting with its true significance as a masterpiece of Mughal architecture.

**4. Poetic Philosophies**

The poem expresses a critical view of colonialism, particularly the cultural insensitivity and economic exploitation that characterized British rule in India. It implicitly advocates for the preservation of cultural heritage and respect for the values and history of colonized peoples.

**5. Comparisons with Other Poets**

- **18th and 19th Century British Poets:** The satirical tone and social commentary in "The Auction" can be compared to the works of poets like Alexander Pope, whose satirical verse often critiqued society's follies. The use of irony and wit aligns with the neoclassical tradition, though Ragavan's subject matter is more modern and culturally specific.

- **Romantic Poets:** While the subject matter differs from the typical Romantic focus on nature and emotion, the poem's criticism of colonial arrogance and the romanticization of India's cultural heritage echoes some aspects of the Romantic spirit. Poets like William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who valued imagination and emotional depth, might appreciate the poem's underlying respect for cultural beauty.

- **Postcolonial Poets:** The poem shares thematic similarities with postcolonial poets like Derek Walcott and A.K. Ramanujan, who often explore the effects of colonialism on culture and identity. Ragavan's poem, like their works, challenges the narrative of colonial superiority and emphasizes the value of indigenous cultures.

**6. Contemporary Poets**

Contemporary poets writing in postcolonial contexts often address similar themes of cultural identity, heritage, and the impacts of colonialism. Poets like Imtiaz Dharker, Nissim Ezekiel, and Agha Shahid Ali explore the complexities of cultural heritage and identity, often blending personal and political themes. Ragavan's work can be seen as part of this broader tradition, using poetry to critique historical injustices and assert the value of cultural preservation.

**7. Conclusion**

"The Auction" by Soman Ragavan is a sharp critique of colonial attitudes towards Indian cultural heritage, using satire and irony to expose the absurdity of valuing a historical monument only for its potential financial gain. The poem's rich language and critical perspective place it within both historical and contemporary literary traditions, resonating with the works of satirical, Romantic, and postcolonial poets.

(5)

Soman Ragavan :

Please make general observations on storytelling, intellectual value of the poem, the place of the poem in Commonwealth literature and other matters you wish to cover.

(6)

ChatGPT : 

### General Observations on "The Auction" by Soman Ragavan

**1. Storytelling and Narrative Technique**

"The Auction" employs a first-person narrative style, presenting the perspective of a British colonial official. This choice is effective for conveying the colonial mindset and allows the poet to use dramatic monologue as a storytelling device. The narrative is structured in a chronological sequence, beginning with the contemplation of demolishing the Taj Mahal, moving through the test auction, and concluding with the realization of its failure. This clear progression helps in understanding the absurdity and futility of the colonial enterprise depicted in the poem.

**2. Intellectual Value**

The intellectual value of "The Auction" lies in its nuanced critique of colonialism and its cultural insensitivity. By focusing on a specific historical anecdote—the potential demolition of the Taj Mahal—the poem highlights the often-overlooked aspects of colonial exploitation beyond mere economic or political domination. The poem invites readers to reflect on the broader implications of colonial attitudes toward conquered lands and peoples, particularly in the realm of cultural heritage and identity. The use of satire serves not only to entertain but also to provoke thought, making the poem an intellectually stimulating piece.

**3. Place in Commonwealth Literature**

As a work from a Mauritian poet, "The Auction" contributes to the rich tapestry of Commonwealth literature, which often deals with themes of postcolonialism, identity, and cultural conflict. Commonwealth literature encompasses a wide range of voices from former British colonies, offering diverse perspectives on the legacy of colonialism. Ragavan's poem aligns with this tradition by addressing the cultural consequences of British rule in India, a common theme in Commonwealth literature.

The poem also exemplifies the Commonwealth tradition of using English—the language of the colonizer—to critique colonial practices and express indigenous experiences. This use of English as a medium for postcolonial expression allows the poem to reach a global audience, fostering cross-cultural understanding and dialogue.

**4. Style and Language**

The poem's use of archaic and colloquial English reflects the historical period it addresses and helps to characterize the colonial officials. The exaggerated and somewhat theatrical language enhances the satirical tone, making the poem both engaging and thought-provoking. The use of phrases like "Bloody hell" and "goddamn land of perdition" not only adds color to the poem but also underscores the colonizers' contempt for the land and people they rule.

**5. Cultural and Historical Significance**

By addressing a specific historical event—the proposed demolition of the Taj Mahal—Ragavan brings attention to the often-ignored cultural heritage aspects of colonial history. The poem serves as a reminder of the colonial disregard for indigenous cultural symbols and highlights the importance of preserving cultural heritage in the face of modernization and exploitation.

**6. Comparative Analysis**

In comparison with other works in Commonwealth literature, Ragavan's poem shares a critical stance toward colonialism with writers like Chinua Achebe, Nadine Gordimer ….. Like these authors, Ragavan uses literature to explore the complexities of postcolonial identity and the lingering effects of colonial rule. The poem's focus on a specific historical event also recalls works like Rudyard Kipling's "The Man Who Would Be King," which, while written from a colonial perspective, also explores the consequences of imperial ambitions.

**7. Overall Impact and Relevance**

"The Auction" remains relevant today as it speaks to the ongoing challenges of cultural preservation and the dangers of valuing material wealth over cultural heritage. The poem's satirical approach makes it accessible and engaging, while its serious underlying message encourages readers to think critically about the legacies of colonialism. In this way, Ragavan's work contributes meaningfully to contemporary discussions on postcolonialism and cultural identity.

(7)

Soman Ragavan :

Thank you very much. Goodbye for now.

(8)

ChatGPT :

You're welcome, Soman Ragavan. It was a pleasure analyzing your poem. Goodbye for now, and feel free to return anytime you wish to share more of your work or discuss literature. Take care!

------------------------