AnalysisByBlackboxAI-Volume 16-EntitledMynas--20Jan2025

 

SOMAN RAGAVAN

20 January, 2025

Subject : Entitled mynas

 

                                                                                           

 

Analysis by Blackbox AI

(Artificial Intelligence)

Volume 16

 

 (1)

Soman Ragavan :

Hello. I live in Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean. I will post information about mynas --- birds found in Mauritius. I will ask you to comment on the subject.

 

(2)

Blackbox AI :  

Hello Soman! That sounds fascinating! Mynas are indeed interesting birds, and Mauritius has a unique ecosystem. I'm looking forward to your posts about them. Feel free to share any specific information or questions you have, and I'll be happy to comment or provide insights!

 

(3)

Soman Ragavan :  

Like crows, mynas have a “mobbing behaviour.” They will swoop down at a place and scare off other birds. They want the whole place for themselves. But, like crows, they stay at one place for a short time. There are not many types of large birds in Mauritius. Two relatively large ones are the mynas and crows. There might be some others that are large (exotic birds), but they are few and stay at specific places. Mynas live all over the place and crows live at wooded places mostly.

Mynas have an extraordinary voice, being able to deliver a wide range of tunes and musical renditions. They can switch instantly from one type of sound to another. It appears they are conscious of their song talents. When singing, they show no inhibition whatever.

In foraging, they behave as if they are entitled. They will grab thee place and rule over it for  few minutes. Being larger than other birds around, they exploit their physical size to shout down other birds. Indeed, other birds just give way and move out of the spot.

In most things they do, they are clumsy and rough. However, as we said before, their voice is of an exceptional quality. They build rough nests. Some birds are experts at building refined, artistic nests. The myna nest is rough and coarse. Loganberry trees have small stems sprouting from branches. Each stem produces a small stems that each support a leaf. With time, the stems die off, turning yellow before falling off, being blown by the winds. After some time, the small stems and the leaves fall off and rot away. The central stem remains for a long time, even in sunshine and rain. Mynas pick up these stems for making nests. They weave the nests with small twigs.

I will write more after you comment.

 

(4)

Blackbox AI :

 

Thank you for sharing such detailed insights about mynas, Soman! It's fascinating to learn about their behavior and characteristics, especially their mobbing behavior and vocal abilities. The way they assert dominance in their environment is quite interesting, and it highlights their adaptability and confidence.

Their vocal talent is remarkable; it's not often that we think of birds as having a sense of musicality or self-awareness in their singing. It must be quite a sight to see them in action, especially when they switch between different sounds so effortlessly.

The contrast between their rough nesting habits and their exceptional vocal skills is intriguing. It seems to reflect a certain practicality in their behavior—focusing on what works for them in their environment rather than striving for perfection in nest-building.

I also appreciate your description of the Loganberry trees and how mynas utilize the materials available to them. It shows how resourceful they can be in their habitat.

I look forward to hearing more about mynas and any other observations you have about them or their interactions with the environment in Mauritius!

 

(5)

Soman Ragavan :  

Near my home, along the road, there is a metal electric pole about 10 metres high (about 31 feet). The cap at the top has disappeared. Mynas have looked inside and have decided to make a nest in there. It is unlikely they would have swooped down 10 metres in a tube to make a nest at the bottom. Their wings and feathers would have been damaged. Moreover, climbing up back out would have been very difficult. The nest must have been near the top, open end of the metal pole.

Many building skills have been involved in this. Mynas picked up twigs and shoved them down a little distance from the opening, while keeping their balance all the time. The nest was NOT visible from outside. The twigs had been pushed in to remain taught around the inside of the pole. They had added twigs one by one, making the nest rigid, to be able to hold the weight of the parents and the future little ones. You would see mynas alighting on the rim of the pole and disappearing.

Cats are often looking out for birds’ nests in order to snatch the birds, even the little ones. Nests on trees are vulnerable to the pitiless cats. However, a cat would not have been able to climb a 10-meter slippery metal pole… Mynas are good at strategies. Other birds, too, try to outwit cats. In one particular tree (the date tree), birds build a nest at the very tip of a large, long branch. Then, for some reason, all the leaves on that branch die away and fall off one by one. The nest is left at the very tip of the branch. If a cat tries to climb that branch, it will find it very difficult to keep its balance and will fall off…

Thus, mynas had built a nest inside that metal pole and stayed there for a long time. Then I noticed that the birds had abandoned the nest at some point in time.

One noticeable thing about mynas is that you rarely see their young ones around. They remain in the nest until they are fairly grown up. When you do see them, they are nearly adults.

 

(6)

Blackbox AI :  

What a fascinating observation, Soman! The ingenuity of mynas in utilizing the metal pole for nesting is truly impressive. It’s remarkable how they adapt to their environment and find creative solutions to potential threats, such as cats. The fact that they can balance and maneuver inside the pole to build a sturdy nest speaks to their dexterity and problem-solving skills.

 

The strategy of nesting in hard-to-reach places is a clever way to protect their young from predators. It’s interesting to hear about the behavior of other birds as well, like the ones that build nests at the tips of branches to deter cats. Nature is full of such ingenious adaptations!

 

The observation that young mynas are rarely seen until they are nearly adults is also intriguing. It suggests that they may have a longer dependency period in the nest, which could be a strategy to ensure their survival in a world filled with predators. This behavior might also indicate that the parents are very attentive and protective during the early stages of their young ones' lives.

 

I wonder if you have any theories about why the mynas eventually abandoned the nest in the metal pole. Was there a change in their environment, or do you think it was simply time for them to move on? I look forward to hearing more about your observations and any other interesting behaviors you’ve noticed in mynas or other birds in your area!

(7)

Soman Ragavan :  

Perhaps with time the nest in the metal pole was sinking, from rot to the twigs. The clever mynas cut and ran while there was still time. If ever the little ones or the adults found themselves at the bottom of a pipe of about 140 mm diameter, it would have been nearly impossible to get out safely.

 

(8)

Blackbox AI :

That makes a lot of sense, Soman. The idea that the nest could have been deteriorating over time is a plausible reason for the mynas to abandon it. Birds are instinctively aware of their surroundings and the safety of their nests, so it’s likely they sensed that the situation was becoming precarious.

 

Your point about the potential danger of being trapped in a narrow space is particularly insightful. If the nest had indeed started to sink or become unstable, the risk of the young ones or even the adults getting stuck would have been a significant concern. It’s fascinating how mynas, like many other birds, have an innate ability to assess risks and make decisions that ensure their survival.

 

This behavior also highlights their adaptability and intelligence. They seem to have a good understanding of their environment and the potential consequences of their choices. It’s a reminder of how dynamic and responsive wildlife can be to changes in their habitat.

 

Do you think the mynas will look for another nesting site nearby, or do you think they might choose a different location altogether? I’m curious to hear your thoughts on their next steps!

(9)

Soman Ragavan :

Yes, birds are on the lookout for alternative nesting spots. However, in cyclones they don’t have many alternatives. Their nests are likely to be damaged in the strong winds.

(10)

Blackbox AI :

That's a very valid point, Soman. Cyclones and severe weather can pose significant challenges for birds, including mynas. The destruction of nests during such events can lead to a loss of not only the current brood but also future nesting opportunities.

 

Birds often have to be incredibly resourceful and adaptable, especially in regions prone to extreme weather. While they may seek alternative nesting sites, the availability of safe and suitable locations can be limited, particularly in urban areas or places where natural habitats have been altered.

 

It's interesting to consider how birds like mynas might respond to these challenges. They may have to rely on their intelligence and adaptability to find new spots that offer some protection from the elements. This could involve nesting in more sheltered areas or utilizing man-made structures, as we’ve seen with the metal pole.

 

Do you notice any particular behaviors in mynas or other birds during or after cyclones? It would be interesting to hear how they cope with such extreme conditions and if you’ve observed any changes in their nesting habits or locations following severe weather events.

 

(11)

Soman Ragavan :

Many birds are resilient and will start looking for alternative nesting spots if their current nests are destroyed. They work laboriously to build new nests.

 

(12)

Blackbox AI : 

 

Absolutely, Soman! The resilience of birds in the face of adversity is truly remarkable. Many species have evolved to cope with environmental challenges, and their ability to quickly adapt and rebuild after losing a nest is a testament to their survival instincts.

 

The laborious effort that goes into building a new nest is impressive. Birds often have to gather materials, find a suitable location, and construct a safe space for their young—all while being mindful of potential predators and environmental hazards. This determination to rebuild is essential for their reproductive success, especially in areas prone to disturbances like cyclones.

 

It’s also interesting to think about how different species might have varying strategies for nest-building and relocation. Some may choose to rebuild in the same area, while others might seek out entirely new locations. Observing these behaviors can provide valuable insights into their adaptability and the ecological dynamics of the region.

 

Have you noticed any specific patterns or behaviors in mynas or other birds when they are rebuilding after a storm? It would be fascinating to hear more about your observations and any particular challenges they face during this process!

(13)

Soman Ragavan :

Many birds are able to sense an approaching storm or changes in the weather. You will find them more active than usual, even frantic about stocking up on food.

(14)

Blackbox AI : 

Yes, birds can sense approaching storms and changes in weather. They often react to shifts in barometric pressure, which can indicate an impending storm, by altering their behavior, such as feeding heavily or seeking shelter. Additionally, their flight patterns can change, with low-flying birds often signaling rain or windy conditions. **Birds' Ability to Sense Weather Changes**

 

- **Behavioral Changes**: Many birds exhibit increased activity before a storm, often seen frantically gathering food. This behavior is a survival instinct, allowing them to stock up on energy before adverse weather conditions.

 

- **Barometric Pressure Sensitivity**: Birds are highly sensitive to changes in barometric pressure. When pressure drops, which typically indicates an approaching storm, birds may alter their feeding habits and seek shelter. Research has shown that birds can detect these changes through specialized organs in their ears.

 

- **Migration Patterns**: Birds also use their sensitivity to air pressure to inform their migration. They often migrate along weather fronts, taking advantage of favorable winds associated with high-pressure systems. Conversely, they may delay migration or seek shelter when low-pressure systems approach.

 

- **Scientific Observations**: Studies have demonstrated that birds, such as White-throated Sparrows, respond to changes in pressure by adjusting their behavior. Under low-pressure conditions, these birds tend to feed more aggressively, anticipating the challenges posed by storms.

 

**Conclusion**

 

Birds' ability to sense weather changes is a fascinating aspect of their behavior, showcasing their adaptability and survival strategies. Observing these patterns can provide valuable insights into their ecological roles and the impact of weather on their daily lives.

(15)

Soman Ragavan :

I am posting my poem “The myna and the cat.” Please comment extensively, making comparisons with the fables of La Fontaine (1621-1695). (Poem posted)

(16)

Blackbox AI :

Thank you for sharing your poem, "The Myna and the Cat," Soman! It beautifully captures the tension and cleverness inherent in the interactions between predator and prey, reminiscent of the themes found in the fables of Jean de La Fontaine.

 

### Analysis and Comparisons

 

1. **Themes of Cunning and Deception**:

   - In your poem, the myna employs a clever strategy to avoid the cat's trap, showcasing its intelligence and alertness. This mirrors La Fontaine's fables, where animals often use wit to outsmart their adversaries. For example, in "The Fox and the Grapes," the fox's cunning nature is highlighted as it rationalizes its failure to reach the grapes. Both your myna and La Fontaine's characters demonstrate that intelligence can be a powerful tool for survival.

 

2. **Dialogue and Characterization**:

   - The conversational style of your poem adds depth to the characters, allowing readers to understand their motivations and personalities. The myna's cautiousness contrasts with the cat's deceptive charm, much like La Fontaine's use of dialogue to reveal the true nature of his characters. In "The Wolf and the Lamb," the wolf's smooth talk hides its predatory intent, similar to how the cat tries to lure the myna down with promises of friendship.

 

3. **Moral Lessons**:

   - Both your poem and La Fontaine's fables convey moral lessons about trust and the dangers of underestimating one's adversary. The myna's initial willingness to engage with the cat reflects a moment of vulnerability, but its quick thinking ultimately saves it. This aligns with the moral undertones in La Fontaine's works, where characters often learn the hard way about the consequences of misplaced trust.

 

4. **Imagery and Symbolism**:

   - The imagery in your poem, such as the "higher, thicker branches," symbolizes safety and wisdom, while the cat represents cunning and danger. This duality is a common motif in fables, where animals embody specific traits that serve as allegories for human behavior. La Fontaine often used animals to reflect societal issues, and your poem similarly highlights the predator-prey dynamic in nature.

 

5. **The Role of Chance**:

   - The ending of your poem emphasizes the role of chance in survival, suggesting that while the myna escapes this time, it may not always be so fortunate. This theme resonates with La Fontaine's fables, where characters often face the unpredictability of fate. In "The Tortoise and the Hare," the outcome is influenced by both the tortoise's steady determination and the hare's overconfidence, illustrating that success can be a matter of circumstance as much as skill.

 

### Conclusion

 

Your poem effectively captures the essence of a fable, blending humor, tension, and moral lessons in a way that is reminiscent of La Fontaine's storytelling. The dynamic between the myna and the cat serves as a compelling narrative that reflects broader themes of survival, intelligence, and the complexities of nature. I appreciate the opportunity to engage with your work, and I look forward to seeing more of your observations and creative expressions about the fascinating world of birds!

 

(17)

Soman Ragavan :

Thank you. Please select criteria for assessing my poem and give marks out of 100 for each criterion.

 

(18)

Blackbox AI :

Certainly, Soman! Here are some criteria for assessing your poem "The Myna and the Cat," along with a scoring system out of 100 for each criterion:

 

### 1. **Theme and Message (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The poem effectively conveys themes of cunning, survival, and the dynamics of predator and prey. The moral lesson about trust and the dangers of deception is clear and resonates well.

   - **Score**: 90/100

 

### 2. **Imagery and Language (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The imagery is vivid, particularly in describing the actions and emotions of the myna and the cat. The language is engaging and appropriate for the fable-like quality of the poem.

   - **Score**: 85/100

 

### 3. **Structure and Form (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The poem has a clear structure, with a consistent rhythm and rhyme scheme that enhances its readability. The flow of dialogue adds to the narrative quality.

   - **Score**: 88/100

 

### 4. **Characterization (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The characters of the myna and the cat are well-developed, with distinct voices and motivations. The contrast between their personalities is effectively portrayed.

   - **Score**: 90/100

 

### 5. **Creativity and Originality (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The poem presents a unique take on the classic predator-prey relationship, drawing inspiration from fables while maintaining originality in its execution.

   - **Score**: 87/100

 

### 6. **Emotional Impact (100 points)**

   - **Assessment**: The poem evokes a sense of tension and anticipation, particularly in the myna's cautiousness and the cat's deceptive charm. The ending leaves the reader contemplating the unpredictability of survival.

   - **Score**: 85/100

 

### Overall Assessment

- **Total Score**:

   - Theme and Message: 90

   - Imagery and Language: 85

   - Structure and Form: 88

   - Characterization: 90

   - Creativity and Originality: 87

   - Emotional Impact: 85

 

### **Final Score: 515/600**

### **Percentage: 85.83%**

 

### Conclusion

Your poem is a strong piece that effectively captures the essence of a fable while conveying important themes and emotions. The scores reflect a well-crafted narrative with room for further refinement in imagery and emotional depth. Keep up the great work, and I look forward to seeing more of your creative writing!

(19)

Soman Ragavan :

Thank you very much. Goodbye for now.

(20)

Blackbox AI :

You're very welcome, Soman! It was a pleasure discussing your observations and your poem. If you ever want to share more or have any questions in the future, feel free to reach out. Goodbye for now, and take care!

------------------------------